PICABench: How Far Are We from Physically Realistic Image Editing?

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2510.17681v2
• Date: Tue, 21 Oct 2025 11:35:57 GMT
• Title: PICABench: How Far Are We from Physically Realistic Image Editing?
• Authors: Yuandong Pu, Le Zhuo, Songhao Han, Jinbo Xing, Kaiwen Zhu, Shuo Cao, Bin Fu, Si Liu, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao, Wenlong Zhang, Xi Chen, Yihao Liu,
• Abstract summary: We introduce PICABench, which systematically evaluates physical realism across eight sub-dimensions.<n>We propose the PICAEval, a reliable evaluation protocol that uses VLM-as-a-judge with per-case, region-level human annotations.<n>We also explore effective solutions by learning physics from videos and construct a training dataset PICA-100K.
• Score: 71.82009431774311
• License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
• Abstract: Image editing has achieved remarkable progress recently. Modern editing models could already follow complex instructions to manipulate the original content. However, beyond completing the editing instructions, the accompanying physical effects are the key to the generation realism. For example, removing an object should also remove its shadow, reflections, and interactions with nearby objects. Unfortunately, existing models and benchmarks mainly focus on instruction completion but overlook these physical effects. So, at this moment, how far are we from physically realistic image editing? To answer this, we introduce PICABench, which systematically evaluates physical realism across eight sub-dimension (spanning optics, mechanics, and state transitions) for most of the common editing operations (add, remove, attribute change, etc.). We further propose the PICAEval, a reliable evaluation protocol that uses VLM-as-a-judge with per-case, region-level human annotations and questions. Beyond benchmarking, we also explore effective solutions by learning physics from videos and construct a training dataset PICA-100K. After evaluating most of the mainstream models, we observe that physical realism remains a challenging problem with large rooms to explore. We hope that our benchmark and proposed solutions can serve as a foundation for future work moving from naive content editing toward physically consistent realism.

Related papers

• PhysChoreo: Physics-Controllable Video Generation with Part-Aware Semantic Grounding [50.454084539837005]
  PhysChoreo is a novel framework that can generate videos with diverse controllability and physical realism from a single image.<n>Our method consists of two stages: first, it estimates the static initial physical properties of all objects in the image through part-aware physical property reconstruction.<n>Then, through temporally instructed and physically editable simulation, it synthesizes high-quality videos with rich dynamic behaviors and physical realism.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-11-25T17:59:04Z)
• PhysMaster: Mastering Physical Representation for Video Generation via Reinforcement Learning [49.88366485306749]
  Video generation models nowadays are capable of generating visually realistic videos, but often fail to adhere to physical laws.<n>We propose PhysMaster, which captures physical knowledge as a representation for guiding video generation models to enhance their physics-awareness.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-10-15T17:59:59Z)
• LikePhys: Evaluating Intuitive Physics Understanding in Video Diffusion Models via Likelihood Preference [57.086932851733145]
  We introduce LikePhys, a training-free method that evaluates intuitive physics in video diffusion models.<n>We benchmark intuitive physics understanding in current video diffusion models.<n> Empirical results show that, despite current models struggling with complex and chaotic dynamics, there is a clear trend of improvement in physics understanding as model capacity and inference settings scale.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-10-13T15:19:07Z)
• TRAVL: A Recipe for Making Video-Language Models Better Judges of Physics Implausibility [70.24211591214528]
  Video generative models produce sequences that violate intuitive physical laws, such as objects floating, teleporting, or morphing.<n>Existing Video-Language Models (VLMs) struggle to identify physics violations, exposing fundamental limitations in their temporal and causal reasoning.<n>We introduce TRAVL, a fine-tuning recipe that combines a balanced training dataset with a trajectory-aware attention module to improve motion encoding.<n>We propose ImplausiBench, a benchmark of 300 videos (150 real, 150 generated) that removes linguistic biases and isolates visual-temporal understanding.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-10-08T21:03:46Z)
• PhysHMR: Learning Humanoid Control Policies from Vision for Physically Plausible Human Motion Reconstruction [52.44375492811009]
  We present PhysHMR, a unified framework that learns a visual-to-action policy for humanoid control in a physics-based simulator.<n>A key component of our approach is the pixel-as-ray strategy, which lifts 2D keypoints into 3D spatial rays and transforms them into global space.<n>PhysHMR produces high-fidelity, physically plausible motion across diverse scenarios, outperforming prior approaches in both visual accuracy and physical realism.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-10-02T21:01:11Z)
• Materialist: Physically Based Editing Using Single-Image Inverse Rendering [47.85234717907478]
  Materialist is a method combining a learning-based approach with physically based progressive differentiable rendering.<n>Our approach enables a range of applications, including material editing, object insertion, and relighting.<n> Experiments demonstrate strong performance across synthetic and real-world datasets.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-01-07T11:52:01Z)
• Learning Action and Reasoning-Centric Image Editing from Videos and Simulations [45.637947364341436]
  AURORA dataset is a collection of high-quality training data, human-annotated and curated from videos and simulation engines. We evaluate an AURORA-finetuned model on a new expert-curated benchmark covering 8 diverse editing tasks. Our model significantly outperforms previous editing models as judged by human raters.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-07-03T19:36:33Z)
• Trajectory Optimization for Physics-Based Reconstruction of 3d Human Pose from Monocular Video [31.96672354594643]
  We focus on the task of estimating a physically plausible articulated human motion from monocular video. Existing approaches that do not consider physics often produce temporally inconsistent output with motion artifacts. We show that our approach achieves competitive results with respect to existing physics-based methods on the Human3.6M benchmark.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-05-24T18:02:49Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.