The original Wigner's friend paradox within a realist toy model
- URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2101.11032v5
- Date: Wed, 20 Oct 2021 15:22:13 GMT
- Title: The original Wigner's friend paradox within a realist toy model
- Authors: Matteo Lostaglio and Joseph Bowles
- Abstract summary: The original Wigner's friend paradox highlights the tension between unitary evolution and collapse in quantum theory.
We present a classical toy model in which the contradicting predictions at the heart of the thought experiment are reproduced.
The debate surrounding the original Wigner's friend thought experiment and its resolution have striking similarities with arguments concerning the nature of the second law of thermodynamics.
- Score: 0.0
- License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
- Abstract: The original Wigner's friend paradox is a gedankenexperiment involving an
observer described by an external agent. The paradox highlights the tension
between unitary evolution and collapse in quantum theory, and is sometimes
taken as requiring a reassessment of the notion of objective reality. In this
note however we present a classical toy model in which (i) The contradicting
predictions at the heart of the thought experiment are reproduced (ii) Every
system is in a well-defined state at all times. The toy model shows how puzzles
such as Wigner's friend's experience of being in a superposition, conflicts
between different agents' descriptions of the experiment, the positioning of
the Heisenberg's cut and the apparent lack of objectivity of measurement
outcomes can be explained within a classical model where there exists an
objective state of affairs about every physical system at all times. Within the
model, the debate surrounding the original Wigner's friend thought experiment
and its resolution have striking similarities with arguments concerning the
nature of the second law of thermodynamics. The same conclusion however does
not apply to more recent extensions of the gedankenexperiment featuring
multiple encapsulated observers, and shows that such extensions are indeed
necessary avoid simple classical explanations.
Related papers
- Understanding Epistemic Language with a Bayesian Theory of Mind [47.001163099930494]
We introduce a cognitive model of epistemic language interpretation grounded in Bayesian inferences.
We validate our model in an experiment where participants watch an agent navigate a maze to find keys hidden in boxes needed to reach their goal, then rate sentences about the agent's beliefs.
arXiv Detail & Related papers (2024-08-21T22:29:56Z) - Thinking twice inside the box: is Wigner's friend really quantum? [0.0]
We argue that the gist of the Wigner's friend paradox can be reproduced without assuming quantum physics.
We show that several recently proposed extended Wigner's friend scenarios can be reproduced by classical thought experiments.
We argue that this difficulty is at the core of other puzzles in the foundations of physics and philosophy.
arXiv Detail & Related papers (2024-02-13T19:00:13Z) - Logic meets Wigner's Friend (and their Friends) [49.1574468325115]
We take a fresh look at Wigner's Friend thought-experiment and some of its more recent variants and extensions.
We discuss various solutions proposed in the literature, focusing on a few questions.
arXiv Detail & Related papers (2023-07-04T13:31:56Z) - Wigner's Friend paradoxes: consistency with weak-contextual and
weak-macroscopic realism models [0.0]
Wigner's friend paradoxes highlight contradictions between measurements made by Friends inside a laboratory and superobservers outside a laboratory.
The contradictions lead to no-go theorems for observer-independent facts, thus challenging concepts of objectivity.
We demonstrate consistency with a contextual weak form of macroscopic realism.
arXiv Detail & Related papers (2022-11-05T11:13:12Z) - Self-Explaining Deviations for Coordination [31.94421561348329]
We focus on a specific subclass of coordination problems in which humans are able to discover self-explaining deviations (SEDs)
SEDs are actions that deviate from the common understanding of what reasonable behavior would be in normal circumstances.
We introduce a novel algorithm, improvement maximizing self-explaining deviations (IMPROVISED), to perform SEDs.
arXiv Detail & Related papers (2022-07-13T20:56:59Z) - Observing Interventions: A logic for thinking about experiments [62.997667081978825]
This paper makes a first step towards a logic of learning from experiments.
Crucial for our approach is the idea that the notion of an intervention can be used as a formal expression of a (real or hypothetical) experiment.
For all the proposed logical systems, we provide a sound and complete axiomatization.
arXiv Detail & Related papers (2021-11-25T09:26:45Z) - Quantum indistinguishability through exchangeable desirable gambles [69.62715388742298]
Two particles are identical if all their intrinsic properties, such as spin and charge, are the same.
Quantum mechanics is seen as a normative and algorithmic theory guiding an agent to assess her subjective beliefs represented as (coherent) sets of gambles.
We show how sets of exchangeable observables (gambles) may be updated after a measurement and discuss the issue of defining entanglement for indistinguishable particle systems.
arXiv Detail & Related papers (2021-05-10T13:11:59Z) - Quantum erasing the memory of Wigner's friend [0.0]
Wigner's friend paradox concerns one of the most puzzling problems of quantum mechanics.
At the core of the paradox lies the description of an observer and the object it measures as a closed system obeying the Schr"odinger equation.
We argue that the three apparently incompatible properties used to question the consistency of quantum mechanics correspond to two logically distinct contexts.
arXiv Detail & Related papers (2020-09-21T14:24:58Z) - Non-Boolean Hidden Variables model reproduces Quantum Mechanics'
predictions for Bell's experiment [91.3755431537592]
Theory aimed to violate Bell's inequalities must start by giving up Boolean logic.
"Hard" problem is to predict the time values when single particles are detected.
"Soft" problem is to explain the violation of Bell's inequalities within (non-Boolean) Local Realism.
arXiv Detail & Related papers (2020-05-20T21:46:35Z) - A strong no-go theorem on the Wigner's friend paradox [0.0]
We prove that if quantum evolution is controllable on the scale of an observer, then one of 'No-Superdeterminism', 'Locality' or 'Absoluteness of Observed Events' must be false.
We show that although the violation of Bell-type inequalities in such scenarios is not in general sufficient to demonstrate the contradiction between those three assumptions, new inequalities can be derived in a theory-independent manner.
arXiv Detail & Related papers (2019-07-12T08:09:44Z)
This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.
This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.