Towards Responsible and Trustworthy Educational Data Mining: Comparing Symbolic, Sub-Symbolic, and Neural-Symbolic AI Methods

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2504.00615v2
• Date: Fri, 11 Apr 2025 11:21:05 GMT
• Title: Towards Responsible and Trustworthy Educational Data Mining: Comparing Symbolic, Sub-Symbolic, and Neural-Symbolic AI Methods
• Authors: Danial Hooshyar, Eve Kikas, Yeongwook Yang, Gustav Šír, Raija Hämäläinen, Tommi Kärkkäinen, Roger Azevedo,
• Abstract summary: This study evaluates symbolic, sub-symbolic, and neural-symbolic AI (NSAI) in terms of generalizability and interpretability.<n>Experiments on Estonian primary school students predicting 7th-grade mathematics national test performance.
• Score: 2.7892842990789553
• License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
• Abstract: Given the demand for responsible and trustworthy AI for education, this study evaluates symbolic, sub-symbolic, and neural-symbolic AI (NSAI) in terms of generalizability and interpretability. Our extensive experiments on balanced and imbalanced self-regulated learning datasets of Estonian primary school students predicting 7th-grade mathematics national test performance showed that symbolic and sub-symbolic methods performed well on balanced data but struggled to identify low performers in imbalanced datasets. Interestingly, symbolic and sub-symbolic methods emphasized different factors in their decision-making: symbolic approaches primarily relied on cognitive and motivational factors, while sub-symbolic methods focused more on cognitive aspects, learnt knowledge, and the demographic variable of gender -- yet both largely overlooked metacognitive factors. The NSAI method, on the other hand, showed advantages by: (i) being more generalizable across both classes -- even in imbalanced datasets -- as its symbolic knowledge component compensated for the underrepresented class; and (ii) relying on a more integrated set of factors in its decision-making, including motivation, (meta)cognition, and learnt knowledge, thus offering a comprehensive and theoretically grounded interpretability framework. These contrasting findings highlight the need for a holistic comparison of AI methods before drawing conclusions based solely on predictive performance. They also underscore the potential of hybrid, human-centred NSAI methods to address the limitations of other AI families and move us closer to responsible AI for education. Specifically, by enabling stakeholders to contribute to AI design, NSAI aligns learned patterns with theoretical constructs, incorporates factors like motivation and metacognition, and strengthens the trustworthiness and responsibility of educational data mining.

Related papers

• Synergizing Self-Regulation and Artificial-Intelligence Literacy Towards Future Human-AI Integrative Learning [92.34299949916134]
  Self-regulated learning (SRL) and Artificial-Intelligence (AI) literacy are becoming key competencies for successful human-AI interactive learning. This study analyzed data from 1,704 Chinese undergraduates using clustering methods to uncover four learner groups.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-03-31T13:41:21Z)
• Unlocking the Potential of Generative AI through Neuro-Symbolic Architectures: Benefits and Limitations [0.7499722271664147]
  Neuro-symbolic artificial intelligence (NSAI) represents a transformative approach in artificial intelligence (AI)<n>NSAI combines deep learning's ability to handle large-scale and unstructured data with the structured reasoning of symbolic methods.<n>This paper systematically studies NSAI architectures, highlighting their unique approaches to integrating neural and symbolic components.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-02-16T21:06:33Z)
• Neurosymbolic AI for Travel Demand Prediction: Integrating Decision Tree Rules into Neural Networks [21.445133878049333]
  This study introduces a Neurosymbolic Artificial Intelligence (Neurosymbolic AI) framework that integrates decision tree (DT)-based symbolic rules with neural networks (NNs) to predict travel demand.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-02-02T05:10:31Z)
• Converging Paradigms: The Synergy of Symbolic and Connectionist AI in LLM-Empowered Autonomous Agents [55.63497537202751]
  Article explores the convergence of connectionist and symbolic artificial intelligence (AI) Traditionally, connectionist AI focuses on neural networks, while symbolic AI emphasizes symbolic representation and logic. Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) highlight the potential of connectionist architectures in handling human language as a form of symbols.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-07-11T14:00:53Z)
• Augmenting deep neural networks with symbolic knowledge: Towards trustworthy and interpretable AI for education [3.627954884906034]
  This research argues that the neural-symbolic family of AI has the potential to address the named challenges. It adapts a neural-symbolic AI framework and accordingly develops an approach called NSAI, that injects and extracts educational knowledge into and from deep neural networks. Our findings reveal that the NSAI approach has better generalizability compared to deep neural networks trained merely on training data.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-11-01T09:38:56Z)
• A Novel Neural-symbolic System under Statistical Relational Learning [47.30190559449236]
  We propose a neural-symbolic framework based on statistical relational learning, referred to as NSF-SRL.<n>Results of symbolic reasoning are utilized to refine and correct the predictions made by deep learning models, while deep learning models enhance the efficiency of the symbolic reasoning process.<n>We believe that this approach sets a new standard for neural-symbolic systems and will drive future research in the field of general artificial intelligence.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-09-16T09:15:37Z)
• Neuro-Symbolic Learning of Answer Set Programs from Raw Data [54.56905063752427]
  Neuro-Symbolic AI aims to combine interpretability of symbolic techniques with the ability of deep learning to learn from raw data. We introduce Neuro-Symbolic Inductive Learner (NSIL), an approach that trains a general neural network to extract latent concepts from raw data. NSIL learns expressive knowledge, solves computationally complex problems, and achieves state-of-the-art performance in terms of accuracy and data efficiency.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-05-25T12:41:59Z)
• Counterfactual Representation Learning with Balancing Weights [74.67296491574318]
  Key to causal inference with observational data is achieving balance in predictive features associated with each treatment type. Recent literature has explored representation learning to achieve this goal. We develop an algorithm for flexible, scalable and accurate estimation of causal effects.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-10-23T19:06:03Z)
• Neuro-symbolic Architectures for Context Understanding [59.899606495602406]
  We propose the use of hybrid AI methodology as a framework for combining the strengths of data-driven and knowledge-driven approaches. Specifically, we inherit the concept of neuro-symbolism as a way of using knowledge-bases to guide the learning progress of deep neural networks.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-03-09T15:04:07Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.