Putting the Segment Anything Model to the Test with 3D Knee MRI - A Comparison with State-of-the-Art Performance

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2504.13340v3
• Date: Thu, 24 Apr 2025 14:18:18 GMT
• Title: Putting the Segment Anything Model to the Test with 3D Knee MRI - A Comparison with State-of-the-Art Performance
• Abstract summary: Menisci are cartilaginous tissue found within the knee that contribute to joint lubrication and weight dispersal.<n> Accurate automated segmentation of menisci would allow for earlier detection and treatment of meniscal abnormalities.
• Score: 2.167419736510938
• License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
• Abstract: Menisci are cartilaginous tissue found within the knee that contribute to joint lubrication and weight dispersal. Damage to menisci can lead to onset and progression of knee osteoarthritis (OA), a condition that is a leading cause of disability, and for which there are few effective therapies. Accurate automated segmentation of menisci would allow for earlier detection and treatment of meniscal abnormalities, as well as shedding more light on the role the menisci play in OA pathogenesis. Focus in this area has mainly used variants of convolutional networks, but there has been no attempt to utilise recent large vision transformer segmentation models. The Segment Anything Model (SAM) is a so-called foundation segmentation model, which has been found useful across a range of different tasks due to the large volume of data used for training the model. In this study, SAM was adapted to perform fully-automated segmentation of menisci from 3D knee magnetic resonance images. A 3D U-Net was also trained as a baseline. It was found that, when fine-tuning only the decoder, SAM was unable to compete with 3D U-Net, achieving a Dice score of $0.81\pm0.03$, compared to $0.87\pm0.03$, on a held-out test set. When fine-tuning SAM end-to-end, a Dice score of $0.87\pm0.03$ was achieved. The performance of both the end-to-end trained SAM configuration and the 3D U-Net were comparable to the winning Dice score ($0.88\pm0.03$) in the IWOAI Knee MRI Segmentation Challenge 2019. Performance in terms of the Hausdorff Distance showed that both configurations of SAM were inferior to 3D U-Net in matching the meniscus morphology. Results demonstrated that, despite its generalisability, SAM was unable to outperform a basic 3D U-Net in meniscus segmentation, and may not be suitable for similar 3D medical image segmentation tasks also involving fine anatomical structures with low contrast and poorly-defined boundaries.

Related papers

• SAMRI-3D: Adapting SAM2 for 3D MRI Segmentation with Global Volume Tokens [7.014494732923701]
  We present SAMRI-3D, a benchmark and method for 3D MRI segmentation with SAM2.<n>The SAMRI-3D benchmark is the largest MRI-only evaluation to date.<n>This full model, SAMRI-3D, attains the best accuracy (0.78) and lowest variance across all 34 datasets.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-07-20T14:48:11Z)
• D3Seg: Dependency-Aware Diffusion for Brain Tumor Segmentation with Missing Modalities [54.87947751720332]
  We propose a novel segmentation model D3Seg to maintain stable performance under missing-modality settings.<n>The proposed model achieves approximately 1.5-2.0% Dice improvement on enhancing tumor (ET) and around 1.0% on tumor core (TC) across multiple missing modality configurations.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-05-21T09:55:42Z)
• Not Quite Anything: Overcoming SAMs Limitations for 3D Medical Imaging [0.0]
  Foundation segmentation models such as SAM and SAM-2 perform well on natural images but struggle with brain MRIs.<n>We propose a compositional alternative where the foundation model output is treated as an additional input channel.<n>We generate SAM-2 prompts by using a lightweight 3D U-Net that was previously trained on MRI segmentation.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-11-22T05:29:27Z)
• VesSAM: Efficient Multi-Prompting for Segmenting Complex Vessel [68.24765319399286]
  We present VesSAM, a powerful and efficient framework tailored for 2D vessel segmentation.<n>VesSAM integrates (1) a convolutional adapter to enhance local texture features, (2) a multi-prompt encoder that fuses anatomical prompts, and (3) a lightweight mask decoder to reduce jagged artifacts.<n>VesSAM consistently outperforms state-of-the-art PEFT-based SAM variants by over 10% Dice and 13% IoU.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-11-02T15:47:05Z)
• AI-Driven MRI-based Brain Tumour Segmentation Benchmarking [0.0]
  This research uses pediatrics Segment Anything Model (SAM), Segment Anything Model 2 (SAM 2), MedSAM, SAM-Med-3D, and nnU-Net to obtain zero-shot inference on the BraTS 2023 adult glioma and pediatrics dataset.<n>Several models exhibit promising Dice scores, particularly SAM and SAM 2 achieving scores of up to 0.894 and 0.893, respectively when given extremely accurate bounding box prompts.<n>However, nnU-Net remains the dominant medical image segmentation network due to the impracticality of providing highly accurate prompts to the models.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-06-25T19:18:26Z)
• SAMRI-2: A Memory-based Model for Cartilage and Meniscus Segmentation in 3D MRIs of the Knee Joint [0.7879983966759583]
  This study introduces a deep learning (DL) method for cartilage and meniscus segmentation from 3D MRIs using memory-based VFMs.<n>We trained four AI models-a CNN-based 3D-VNet, two automatic transformer-based models (SaMRI2D and SaMRI3D), and a transformer-based promptable memory-based VFM (SAMRI-2)-on 3D knee MRIs from 270 patients.<n>SAMRI-2 model, trained with HSS, outperformed all other models, achieving an average improvement of 5 points, with a peak improvement of 12 points for tibial cartilage.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-02-14T21:18:01Z)
• Lightweight Method for Interactive 3D Medical Image Segmentation with Multi-Round Result Fusion [7.158573385931718]
  Segment Anything Model (SAM) has drawn widespread attention due to its zero-shot generalization capabilities in interactive segmentation.<n>We propose Lightweight Interactive Network for 3D Medical Image (LIM-Net) as a novel approach demonstrating the potential of compact CNN-based models.<n>LIM-Net initiates segmentation by generating a 2D prompt mask from user hints.<n>It exhibits stronger generalization to unseen data compared to SAM-based models, with competitive accuracy while requiring fewer interactions.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-12-11T11:52:16Z)
• Brain Tumor Classification on MRI in Light of Molecular Markers [61.77272414423481]
  Co-deletion of the 1p/19q gene is associated with clinical outcomes in low-grade gliomas.<n>This study aims to utilize a specially MRI-based convolutional neural network for brain cancer detection.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-09-29T07:04:26Z)
• MedSegMamba: 3D CNN-Mamba Hybrid Architecture for Brain Segmentation [15.514511820130474]
  We develop a 3D patch-based hybrid CNN-Mamba model for subcortical brain segmentation. Our model's performance was validated against several benchmarks.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-09-12T02:19:19Z)
• Novel adaptation of video segmentation to 3D MRI: efficient zero-shot knee segmentation with SAM2 [1.6237741047782823]
  We introduce a method for zero-shot, single-prompt segmentation of 3D knee MRI by adapting Segment Anything Model 2. By treating slices from 3D medical volumes as individual video frames, we leverage SAM2's advanced capabilities to generate motion- and spatially-aware predictions. We demonstrate that SAM2 can efficiently perform segmentation tasks in a zero-shot manner with no additional training or fine-tuning.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-08-08T21:39:15Z)
• MA-SAM: Modality-agnostic SAM Adaptation for 3D Medical Image Segmentation [58.53672866662472]
  We introduce a modality-agnostic SAM adaptation framework, named as MA-SAM. Our method roots in the parameter-efficient fine-tuning strategy to update only a small portion of weight increments. By injecting a series of 3D adapters into the transformer blocks of the image encoder, our method enables the pre-trained 2D backbone to extract third-dimensional information from input data.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-09-16T02:41:53Z)
• 3DSAM-adapter: Holistic adaptation of SAM from 2D to 3D for promptable tumor segmentation [52.699139151447945]
  We propose a novel adaptation method for transferring the segment anything model (SAM) from 2D to 3D for promptable medical image segmentation. Our model can outperform domain state-of-the-art medical image segmentation models on 3 out of 4 tasks, specifically by 8.25%, 29.87%, and 10.11% for kidney tumor, pancreas tumor, colon cancer segmentation, and achieve similar performance for liver tumor segmentation.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-06-23T12:09:52Z)
• CNN-based fully automatic wrist cartilage volume quantification in MR Image [55.41644538483948]
  The U-net convolutional neural network with additional attention layers provides the best wrist cartilage segmentation performance. The error of cartilage volume measurement should be assessed independently using a non-MRI method.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-06-22T14:19:06Z)
• 3-Dimensional Deep Learning with Spatial Erasing for Unsupervised Anomaly Segmentation in Brain MRI [55.97060983868787]
  We investigate whether using increased spatial context by using MRI volumes combined with spatial erasing leads to improved unsupervised anomaly segmentation performance. We compare 2D variational autoencoder (VAE) to their 3D counterpart, propose 3D input erasing, and systemically study the impact of the data set size on the performance. Our best performing 3D VAE with input erasing leads to an average DICE score of 31.40% compared to 25.76% for the 2D VAE.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-09-14T09:17:27Z)
• Volumetric Medical Image Segmentation: A 3D Deep Coarse-to-fine Framework and Its Adversarial Examples [74.92488215859991]
  We propose a novel 3D-based coarse-to-fine framework to efficiently tackle these challenges. The proposed 3D-based framework outperforms their 2D counterparts by a large margin since it can leverage the rich spatial information along all three axes. We conduct experiments on three datasets, the NIH pancreas dataset, the JHMI pancreas dataset and the JHMI pathological cyst dataset.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-10-29T15:39:19Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.