Is Bohmian mechanics missing some motion? Why a recent experiment is inconclusive

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2511.17215v1
• Date: Fri, 21 Nov 2025 12:52:19 GMT
• Title: Is Bohmian mechanics missing some motion? Why a recent experiment is inconclusive
• Authors: Mordecai Waegell,
• Abstract summary: A recent experiment raises a supposed challenge to Bohmian mechanics.<n>The experiment is not observing stationary states as claimed, but rather the time-averaged density of wave pulses which reflect off the potential step.<n>We discuss a generalized Madelung fluid model where this velocity is given physical meaning, and show how it roughly agrees with the authors' concept of an evanescent De Broglie speed.
• Score: 0.0
• License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
• Abstract: A recent experiment raises a supposed challenge to Bohmian mechanics, claiming to observe stationary states, which should have zero Bohm velocity, while indirectly measuring a nonzero speed based on how an evanescent wavefunction spreads from one waveguide to another coupled waveguide. There were numerous problems this experiment and how it was interpreted. First, the experiment is not observing stationary states as claimed, but rather the time-averaged density of wave pulses which reflect off the potential step. Second, the proposed method for measuring a propagation speed is shown to be invalid for true stationary states. Third, the invalid method was misapplied to the time-averaged density, and this is shown to have created the false impression that it yields correct speed values for stationary states. These issues notwithstanding, for a wavefunction $ψ= Re^{iS/\hbar}$, the velocity of interest, $\vec{v}_s = -\frac{\hbar}{m}\frac{\vec{\nabla}R}{R}$, is different than the Bohm velocity $\vec{v}_B=\frac{1}{m}\vec{\nabla}S$, and may be nonzero for stationary states. So, even though we do not think this experiment makes a compelling case for it, if $\vec{v}_s$ is somehow associated with real physical motion, then this motion is indeed absent from Bohmian mechanics, as the authors contend. We discuss a generalized Madelung fluid model where this velocity is given physical meaning, and show how it roughly agrees with the authors' concept of an evanescent De Broglie speed.

Related papers

• The measured speed in the evanescent regime reflects the spatial decay of the wavefunction, not particle motion [0.8460698440162889]
  We show that v quantifies the spatial gradient of the wavefunctions amplitude, a geometric property of the guiding field, not the kinematical velocity of point-like particles.<n>The experiment does not challenge but rather illustrates the clean ontological separation between the wave and particle aspects inherent to Bohmian mechanics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-12-18T14:21:53Z)
• Reaffirming a Challenge to Bohmian Mechanics [0.0]
  We report the measurement of the speed of tunnelling particles using a coupled waveguide system.<n>The measured speed was found to disagree with the standard guiding equation of Bohmian mechanics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-09-08T11:56:04Z)
• Comment on "Energy-speed relationship of quantum particles challenges Bohmian mechanics" [0.0]
  In their recent paper they report an "energy-speed relationship" for quantum particles in evanescent states.<n>Authors argue that their findings challenge the validity of Bohmian particle dynamics.<n>We explain why this claim is false and the experimental findings are in perfect agreement with Bohmian mechanics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-08-06T14:14:13Z)
• Tunnelling photons pose no challenge to Bohmian machanics [10.618067065229939]
  Recently, Sharoglazova et al. performed an experiment measuring the energy-velocity relationship and Bohmian velocity in coupled waveguides.<n>Here, we demonstrate this experiment poses no challenge to Bohmian mechanics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-07-27T01:50:13Z)
• Production and stabilization of a spin mixture of ultracold dipolar Bose gases [39.58317527488534]
  We present experimental results for a mixture composed of the two lowest Zeeman states of $162$Dy atoms.<n>Due to an interference phenomenon, the rate for such inelastic processes is dramatically reduced with respect to the Wigner threshold law.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-07-11T17:37:01Z)
• Test of transient deviations from Quantum Mechanics in Bell's experiment [41.94295877935867]
  The conflict between Quantum Mechanics (QM) and Local Realism is most noticeable in the correlations observed between distant regions of a spatially spread entangled state. It has been hypothesized that transient deviations (from the values predicted by QM) may be observed if the correlations are measured in a time shorter than L/c. We present the results of such a test performed on a specially designed optical Bell setup with a distance between stations up to 24 m in straight line.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-04-15T13:01:30Z)
• Coherent transfer of the transverse momentum of an optical vortex beam to the motion of a single trapped ion [22.42090005507693]
  We demonstrate the excitation, using a structured light beam carrying orbital angular momentum, of the center of mass motion of a single atom. We characterize the coherent interaction by an effective transverse Lamb-Dicke factor $etamathrmexp_perp62(5)$ which is in agreement with our theoretical prediction $etamathrmtheo_perp57(1)$
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-06-10T06:15:08Z)
• Developments of Bohmian Mechanics [0.0]
  Bohmian mechanics is a deterministic theory of quantum mechanics. It is not applicable to stationary states, since the velocity field for stationary states is the zero function. An alternative to Bohmian mechanics has been formulated, based on a conservation of energy equation.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-10-04T01:30:03Z)
• Zitterbewegung of massless particles [91.3755431537592]
  Zitterbewegung of massless particles with an arbitrary spin is analyzed in various representations. Zitterbewegung takes place in any representation except for the Foldy-Wouthuysen one.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-08-12T14:16:44Z)
• Zitterbewegung and Klein-tunneling phenomena for transient quantum waves [77.34726150561087]
  We show that the Zitterbewegung effect manifests itself as a series of quantum beats of the particle density in the long-time limit. We also find a time-domain where the particle density of the point source is governed by the propagation of a main wavefront. The relative positions of these wavefronts are used to investigate the time-delay of quantum waves in the Klein-tunneling regime.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-03-09T21:27:02Z)
• External and internal wave functions: de Broglie's double-solution theory? [77.34726150561087]
  We propose an interpretative framework for quantum mechanics corresponding to the specifications of Louis de Broglie's double-solution theory. The principle is to decompose the evolution of a quantum system into two wave functions. For Schr"odinger, the particles are extended and the square of the module of the (internal) wave function of an electron corresponds to the density of its charge in space.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-01-13T13:41:24Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.