On the Slow Convergence to Trivial Solutions of Algorithms for Hard Optimization Problems

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2608.18910v1
• Date: Wed, 19 Aug 2026 13:40:11 GMT
• Title: On the Slow Convergence to Trivial Solutions of Algorithms for Hard Optimization Problems
• Abstract summary: We study the finite-size behavior of some optimization algorithms across easy, intermediate, and hard regimes.<n>In the intermediate regime where instances are already highly constrained, local algorithms achieve solutions substantially better than their predicted performance in the high-constraint-density limit.<n>This gap between finite-regime and behavior has important practical implications.
• Score: 5.1739750649736305
• License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
• Abstract: Hard combinatorial optimization problems, many of which are NP-hard, present fundamental algorithmic challenges. Average-case analysis on random instances has emerged as a powerful framework for understanding typical algorithmic performance beyond worst-case guarantees. A substantial body of work has established negative results: for sufficiently hard instances (often controlled by the underlying graph connectivity/constraints density), no known polynomial-time algorithm can significantly outperform naive heuristics in the double asymptotic limit where both problem size and constraints density tend to infinity. We revisit this picture by studying the finite-size behavior of some optimization algorithms across easy, intermediate, and hard regimes. Through rigorous analysis of large-graph asymptotics combined with numerical experiments on canonical problems (maximum independent set and maximum $K$-SAT), we demonstrate that while algorithms do eventually converge to theoretically predicted bounds, this convergence can be remarkably slow. In the intermediate regime where instances are already highly constrained, local algorithms achieve solutions substantially better than their predicted performance in the high-constraint-density limit. This gap between finite-regime and asymptotic behavior has important practical implications: sophisticated algorithmic design remains crucial even when asymptotic theory predicts inevitable failure.

Related papers

• Scalable First-order Method for Certifying Optimal k-Sparse GLMs [9.613635592922174]
  We propose a first-order proximal gradient algorithm to solve the perspective relaxation of the problem within a BnB framework.<n>We show that our approach significantly accelerates dual bound computations and is highly effective in providing optimality certificates for large-scale problems.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-02-13T17:14:18Z)
• Instance-Optimality in Interactive Decision Making: Toward a Non-Asymptotic Theory [30.061707627742766]
  We aim for instance-optimality, a strong notion of adaptivity which asserts that, on any particular problem instance, the algorithm under consideration outperforms all consistent algorithms. In this paper, we take the first step toward developing a non-asymptotic theory of instance-optimal decision making with general function approximation.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-04-24T21:51:58Z)
• A Sequential Deep Learning Algorithm for Sampled Mixed-integer Optimisation Problems [0.3867363075280544]
  We introduce and analyse two efficient algorithms for mixed-integer optimisation problems. We show that both algorithms exhibit finite-time convergence towards the optimal solution. We establish quantitatively the efficacy of these algorithms by means of three numerical tests.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-01-25T17:10:52Z)
• Faster Algorithm and Sharper Analysis for Constrained Markov Decision Process [56.55075925645864]
  The problem of constrained decision process (CMDP) is investigated, where an agent aims to maximize the expected accumulated discounted reward subject to multiple constraints. A new utilities-dual convex approach is proposed with novel integration of three ingredients: regularized policy, dual regularizer, and Nesterov's gradient descent dual. This is the first demonstration that nonconcave CMDP problems can attain the lower bound of $mathcal O (1/epsilon)$ for all complexity optimization subject to convex constraints.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-10-20T02:57:21Z)
• Efficient Methods for Structured Nonconvex-Nonconcave Min-Max Optimization [98.0595480384208]
  We propose a generalization extraient spaces which converges to a stationary point. The algorithm applies not only to general $p$-normed spaces, but also to general $p$-dimensional vector spaces.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-10-31T21:35:42Z)
• An Asymptotically Optimal Primal-Dual Incremental Algorithm for Contextual Linear Bandits [129.1029690825929]
  We introduce a novel algorithm improving over the state-of-the-art along multiple dimensions. We establish minimax optimality for any learning horizon in the special case of non-contextual linear bandits.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-10-23T09:12:47Z)
• The limits of min-max optimization algorithms: convergence to spurious non-critical sets [82.74514886461257]
  min-max optimization algorithms encounter problems far greater because of the existence of periodic cycles and similar phenomena. We show that there exist algorithms that do not attract any points of the problem. We illustrate such challenges in simple to almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost almost
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-06-16T10:49:27Z)
• Fast Objective & Duality Gap Convergence for Non-Convex Strongly-Concave Min-Max Problems with PL Condition [52.08417569774822]
  This paper focuses on methods for solving smooth non-concave min-max problems, which have received increasing attention due to deep learning (e.g., deep AUC)
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-06-12T00:32:21Z)
• Beyond Worst-Case Analysis in Stochastic Approximation: Moment Estimation Improves Instance Complexity [58.70807593332932]
  We study oracle complexity of gradient based methods for approximation problems. We focus on instance-dependent complexity instead of worst case complexity. Our proposed algorithm and its analysis provide a theoretical justification for the success of moment estimation.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-06-08T09:25:47Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.