Homer nodded once more. Von Neumann's misreading of the Compton-Simon experiment and its fallout

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14610v1
• Date: Fri, 24 Feb 2023 12:00:00 GMT
• Title: Homer nodded once more. Von Neumann's misreading of the Compton-Simon experiment and its fallout
• Authors: R. N. Sen
• Abstract summary: We compare von Neumann's account with the Compton-Simon paper. We find that von Neumann had misinterpreted the experiment as consisting of two successive measurements. The quantum measurement problem may be better understood as the problem of establishing that the two are compatible with each other.
• Score: 0.0
• License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
• Abstract: In his book `Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics', von Neumann asserted the following: the Compton-Simon experiment showed that the state vector must collapse upon measurement of any self-adjoint operator. Comparing von Neumann's account with the Compton-Simon paper, we find that von Neumann had misinterpreted the experiment as consisting of two successive measurements (which gave identical results), whereas the experiment only measured two angles on the same photographic plate. Note, however, that the state vector must collapse upon measurement of an additively-conserved quantity; otherwise the conservation law could be violated. Next, it turns out that the mathematical problem of explaining collapse is not fully defined until one specifies the nature of the apparatus. If the apparatus does not have a `classical description', the problem is insoluble, even if the measurement is only approximate (Fine, Simony, Brown, Simony and Busch); but if it does, the problem is soluble within Schroedinger dynamics (with a time-dependent hamiltonian) for additively-conserved observables. The solution, a modification of Sewell's, shows that the state vector has collapsed, but it does not reveal the eigenvalue of the collapsed state. The collapse is irreversible, and results from the interplay of additive conservation laws with the quantum measurement postulate. Indeed, the quantum measurement problem - as expounded by Wigner - may be better understood as the problem of establishing that the two are compatible with each other; it has little relevance to actual measurements.

Related papers

• Measuring the Evolution of Entanglement in Compton Scattering [101.11630543545151]
  The behavior of quantum entanglement during scattering is identical to the behavior of initially classically correlated photons up to a constant factor equal to two. Our dedicated experiment with photons confirms these results and explains the "Puzzle of Decoherence" observed recently.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-06-20T14:21:23Z)
• Solving the Zeh problem about the density operator with higher-order statistics [2.5966580648312223]
  We show that the two mixtures imagined by Zeh, with the same rho, should however be distinguished. We show that this result suppresses a restriction unduly installed on statistical mixtures, but does not affect the general use of rho.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-06-07T09:19:23Z)
• Measurement incompatibility is strictly stronger than disturbance [44.99833362998488]
  Heisenberg argued that measurements irreversibly alter the state of the system on which they are acting, causing an irreducible disturbance on subsequent measurements. This article shows that measurement incompatibility is indeed a sufficient condition for irreversibility of measurement disturbance. However, we exhibit a toy theory, termed the minimal classical theory (MCT), that is a counterexample for the converse implication.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-05-26T13:47:00Z)
• Observation of partial and infinite-temperature thermalization induced by repeated measurements on a quantum hardware [62.997667081978825]
  We observe partial and infinite-temperature thermalization on a quantum superconducting processor. We show that the convergence does not tend to a completely mixed (infinite-temperature) state, but to a block-diagonal state in the observable basis.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-11-14T15:18:11Z)
• Multiple measurements on an uncollapsed entangled two-photon state [0.0]
  I derive conditions, under which two measurements can be taken on the uncollapsed photon-pair state. The measurements taken by both detectors in this situation are uncorrelated. If experimental results of the proposed experiment disagree with the predictions -- results measured on the quantum state are correlated, new space-time distribution of the quantum state's collapse has to be proposed.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-10-12T09:34:48Z)
• Experimental demonstration of optimal unambiguous two-out-of-four quantum state elimination [52.77024349608834]
  A core principle of quantum theory is that non-orthogonal quantum states cannot be perfectly distinguished with single-shot measurements. Here we implement a quantum state elimination measurement which unambiguously rules out two of four pure, non-orthogonal quantum states.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-06-30T18:00:01Z)
• A theory of quantum (statistical) measurement [0.0]
  We propose a theory of quantum (statistical) measurement which is close, in spirit, to Hepp's theory. We make a three-fold assumption: the measurement is not instantaneous, it lasts a finite amount of time and is, up to arbitrary accuracy, performed in a finite region of space. The fact that no irreversibility is attached to the process of measurement is shown to follow from the author's theory of irreversibility.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-05-25T16:56:37Z)
• Von Neumann's book, the Compton-Simon experiment and the collapse hypothesis [0.0]
  We find that von Neumann had relied on his phenomenal memory rather than the printed Compton-Simon paper, and his memory had failed him for once. An Appendix raises some questions for historians of physics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-01-04T10:50:08Z)
• Events in quantum mechanics are maximally non-absolute [0.9176056742068814]
  We prove that quantum correlations can be maximally non-absolute according to both quantifiers. We show that chained Bell inequalities (and relaxations thereof) are also valid constraints for Wigner's experiment.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-12-19T21:15:16Z)
• Quantum indistinguishability through exchangeable desirable gambles [69.62715388742298]
  Two particles are identical if all their intrinsic properties, such as spin and charge, are the same. Quantum mechanics is seen as a normative and algorithmic theory guiding an agent to assess her subjective beliefs represented as (coherent) sets of gambles. We show how sets of exchangeable observables (gambles) may be updated after a measurement and discuss the issue of defining entanglement for indistinguishable particle systems.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-05-10T13:11:59Z)
• Non-equilibrium stationary states of quantum non-Hermitian lattice models [68.8204255655161]
  We show how generic non-Hermitian tight-binding lattice models can be realized in an unconditional, quantum-mechanically consistent manner. We focus on the quantum steady states of such models for both fermionic and bosonic systems.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-03-02T18:56:44Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.