Payout Races and Congested Channels: A Formal Analysis of Security in the Lightning Network

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02147v1
• Date: Fri, 3 May 2024 14:52:47 GMT
• Title: Payout Races and Congested Channels: A Formal Analysis of Security in the Lightning Network
• Abstract summary: The Lightning Network is a payment channel network designed to resolve Bitcoin's scalability issues through fast off-chain transactions. Several vulnerabilities have been manually discovered, but to-date there have been few works systematically analyzing the security of the Lightning Network. We take a foundational approach to analyzing the security of the Lightning Network with the help of formal methods.
• Score: 8.397189036839956
• License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
• Abstract: The Lightning Network, a payment channel network with a market cap of over 192M USD, is designed to resolve Bitcoin's scalability issues through fast off-chain transactions. There are multiple Lightning Network client implementations, all of which conform to the same textual specifications known as BOLTs. Several vulnerabilities have been manually discovered, but to-date there have been few works systematically analyzing the security of the Lightning Network. In this work, we take a foundational approach to analyzing the security of the Lightning Network with the help of formal methods. Based on the BOLTs' specifications, we build a detailed formal model of the Lightning Network's single-hop payment protocol and verify it using the Spin model checker. Our model captures both concurrency and error semantics of the payment protocol. We then define several security properties which capture the correct intermediate operation of the protocol, ensuring that the outcome is always certain to both channel peers, and using them we re-discover a known attack previously reported in the literature along with a novel attack, referred to as a Payout Race. A Payout Race consists of a particular sequence of events that can lead to an ambiguity in the protocol in which innocent users can unwittingly lose funds. We confirm the practicality of this attack by reproducing it in a local testbed environment.

Related papers

• Enabling Threshold Custody for the Lightning Network with Nested Threshold Multi-Signatures [0.71747343065587]
  We present Iceberg, a new cryptographic primitive for thresholdizing one participant inside a multi-signature protocol.<n> Iceberg enables one side of a Lightning channel to operate as a $t$-of-$n$ threshold group while appearing to the counterparty as a standard MuSig2 participant.<n>Our measurements show that thresholdizing a Lightning channel incurs only modest overhead, since a threshold group tolerating one corrupted member sustains over $93%$ of the payment throughput of an unmodified endpoint.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-08-21T03:20:09Z)
• Security Analysis of Bitcoin's V2 Transport Protocol: Exploiting Design Implications for Sustained Eclipse and Downgrade Attacks [2.0625936401496237]
  Bitcoin introduced a new protocol for the encryption of peer-to-peer (P2P) communication.<n>This work examines the current viability of said attacks and concludes that while they are now remediated, alternative attacks and paths to similar objectives exist.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-05-19T11:50:57Z)
• Repurposing Backdoors for Good: Ephemeral Intrinsic Proofs for Verifiable Aggregation in Cross-silo Federated Learning [30.440611659881494]
  We propose a lightweight architecture that shifts from cryptographic proofs to textitIntrinsic Proofs<n>We harness Catastrophic Forgetting to embed verification signals directly into model parameters.<n>Our approach achieves over $1000times$ speedup on ResNet-18 compared to cryptographic baselines, effectively scaling to large models.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-03-11T12:04:18Z)
• Automated Side-Channel Analysis of Cryptographic Protocol Implementations [9.38081874899831]
  We extract the first formal model of WhatsApp from its implementation.<n>We identify a known clone-attack against post-compromise security.<n>We introduce a methodology to analyze cryptographic protocol implementations for their resilience to side-channel attacks.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-11-14T15:13:49Z)
• Model Checking the Security of the Lightning Network [0.7366405857677227]
  The Lightning Network is a payment channel network built for Bitcoin that is already used in practice.<n>We formalize the protocol in TLA+ and formally specify the security property that honest users are guaranteed to retrieve their correct balance.<n>We make model checking the Lightning Network possible using two refinement steps that we verify using proofs.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-05-21T14:22:34Z)
• Commit-Reveal$^2$: Securing Randomness Beacons with Randomized Reveal Order in Smart Contracts [25.885166716453153]
  We present Commit-Reveal$2$, a layered design for blockchain deployments that cryptographically randomizes the final reveal order.<n>The protocol is architected as a hybrid system, where routine coordination runs off chain for efficiency.<n>We release a publicly verifiable prototype and evaluation artifacts to support replication and adoption in blockchain applications.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-04-04T21:05:51Z)
• A Formally Verified Lightning Network [0.0]
  We use formal verification to prove that the Lightning Network (LN) always safeguards the funds of honest users. We provide a custom implementation of (a simplification of) LN, express the desired security goals and, for the first time, provide a machine checkable proof that they are upheld under every scenario.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-03-10T11:33:22Z)
• Atomic Transfer Graphs: Secure-by-design Protocols for Heterogeneous Blockchain Ecosystems [7.312229214872541]
  We propose a framework for generating secure-by-design protocols that realize common security and functionality goals. The resulting protocols build upon Timelock Contracts (CTLCs), a novel minimal smart contract functionality. Our framework is the first to provide generic and provably secure protocols for all these use cases while matching or improving the performance of existing use-case-specific protocols.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-01-29T17:25:53Z)
• CryptoFormalEval: Integrating LLMs and Formal Verification for Automated Cryptographic Protocol Vulnerability Detection [41.94295877935867]
  We introduce a benchmark to assess the ability of Large Language Models to autonomously identify vulnerabilities in new cryptographic protocols. We created a dataset of novel, flawed, communication protocols and designed a method to automatically verify the vulnerabilities found by the AI agents.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-11-20T14:16:55Z)
• BlockFound: Customized blockchain foundation model for anomaly detection [47.04595143348698]
  BlockFound is a customized foundation model for anomaly blockchain transaction detection. We introduce a series of customized designs to model the unique data structure of blockchain transactions. BlockFound is the only method that successfully detects anomalous transactions on Solana with high accuracy.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-10-05T05:11:34Z)
• FORAY: Towards Effective Attack Synthesis against Deep Logical Vulnerabilities in DeFi Protocols [7.413607595641641]
  We introduce Foray, a highly effective attack synthesis framework against deep logical bugs in DeFi protocols. Based on our DSL, we first compile a given DeFi protocol into a token flow graph, our graphical representation of DeFi protocols. Then, we design an efficient sketch generation method to synthesize attack sketches for a certain attack goal.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-07-08T19:35:48Z)
• EmInspector: Combating Backdoor Attacks in Federated Self-Supervised Learning Through Embedding Inspection [53.25863925815954]
  Federated self-supervised learning (FSSL) has emerged as a promising paradigm that enables the exploitation of clients' vast amounts of unlabeled data. While FSSL offers advantages, its susceptibility to backdoor attacks has not been investigated. We propose the Embedding Inspector (EmInspector) that detects malicious clients by inspecting the embedding space of local models.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-05-21T06:14:49Z)
• Sequencer Level Security [2.756899615600916]
  We introduce the Sequencer Level Security (SLS) protocol, an enhancement to sequencing protocols of rollups. We describe the mechanics of the protocol for both the transactions submitted to the rollup mempool, as well as transactions originating from Layer one. We implement a prototype of the SLS protocol, Zircuit, which is built on top of Geth and the OP stack.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-05-03T02:47:40Z)
• A Formal Analysis of SCTP: Attack Synthesis and Patch Verification [7.331862211069559]
  We study the security of the SCTP design, taking a rigorous approach rooted in formal methods. We define 4 attacker models - Off-Path, where the attacker is an outsider that can spoof the port and IP of a peer; Evil-Server, where the attacker is a malicious peer; Replay, where an attacker can capture and replay, but not modify, packets; and On-Path, where the attacker controls the channel between peers.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-03-08T20:38:56Z)
• LookAhead: Preventing DeFi Attacks via Unveiling Adversarial Contracts [15.071155232677643]
  Decentralized Finance (DeFi) incidents have resulted in financial damages exceeding 3 billion US dollars. Current detection tools face significant challenges in identifying attack activities effectively. We propose a new direction for detecting DeFi attacks that focuses on identifying adversarial contracts.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-01-14T11:39:33Z)
• Collaborative Learning Framework to Detect Attacks in Transactions and Smart Contracts [26.70294159598272]
  This paper presents a novel collaborative learning framework designed to detect attacks in blockchain transactions and smart contracts. Our framework exhibits the capability to classify various types of blockchain attacks, including intricate attacks at the machine code level. Our framework achieves a detection accuracy of approximately 94% through extensive simulations and 91% in real-time experiments with a throughput of over 2,150 transactions per second.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-08-30T07:17:20Z)
• One-bit Flip is All You Need: When Bit-flip Attack Meets Model Training [54.622474306336635]
  A new weight modification attack called bit flip attack (BFA) was proposed, which exploits memory fault inject techniques. We propose a training-assisted bit flip attack, in which the adversary is involved in the training stage to build a high-risk model to release.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-08-12T09:34:43Z)
• Flooding with Absorption: An Efficient Protocol for Heterogeneous Bandits over Complex Networks [30.94416632071414]
  We consider a multi-agent setting where each agent solves their own bandit instance endowed with a different set of arms. Their goal is to minimize their group regret while collaborating via some communication protocol over a given network. We propose a new protocol called Flooding with Absorption (FwA) to mitigate the issue of high communication costs incurred by flooding in complex networks.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-03-09T17:44:58Z)
• Refined Bitcoin Security-Latency Under Network Delay [35.16231062731263]
  We study how secure a block is after it becomes $k$-deep in the chain. We analyze the race between adversarial and honest chains in three different phases. We find the probability distribution of the growth of the adversarial chains under models similar to those in [Guo, Ren; AFT 2022] when a target block becomes $k$-deep in the chain.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-12-02T18:54:30Z)
• Combining Graph Neural Networks with Expert Knowledge for Smart Contract Vulnerability Detection [37.7763374870026]
  Existing efforts for contract security analysis rely on rigid rules defined by experts, which are labor-intensive and non-scalable. We propose a novel temporal message propagation network to extract the graph feature from the normalized graph, and combine the graph feature with designed expert patterns to yield a final detection system.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-07-24T13:16:30Z)
• ESCORT: Ethereum Smart COntRacTs Vulnerability Detection using Deep Neural Network and Transfer Learning [80.85273827468063]
  Existing machine learning-based vulnerability detection methods are limited and only inspect whether the smart contract is vulnerable. We propose ESCORT, the first Deep Neural Network (DNN)-based vulnerability detection framework for smart contracts. We show that ESCORT achieves an average F1-score of 95% on six vulnerability types and the detection time is 0.02 seconds per contract.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-03-23T15:04:44Z)
• Online Adversarial Attacks [57.448101834579624]
  We formalize the online adversarial attack problem, emphasizing two key elements found in real-world use-cases. We first rigorously analyze a deterministic variant of the online threat model. We then propose algoname, a simple yet practical algorithm yielding a provably better competitive ratio for $k=2$ over the current best single threshold algorithm.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-03-02T20:36:04Z)
• Quantum Multi-Solution Bernoulli Search with Applications to Bitcoin's Post-Quantum Security [67.06003361150228]
  A proof of work (PoW) is an important cryptographic construct enabling a party to convince others that they invested some effort in solving a computational task. In this work, we examine the hardness of finding such chain of PoWs against quantum strategies. We prove that the chain of PoWs problem reduces to a problem we call multi-solution Bernoulli search, for which we establish its quantum query complexity.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-12-30T18:03:56Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.