Exploring the Limitations of Mamba in COPY and CoT Reasoning

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2410.03810v3
• Date: Thu, 29 May 2025 03:19:51 GMT
• Title: Exploring the Limitations of Mamba in COPY and CoT Reasoning
• Authors: Ruifeng Ren, Zhicong Li, Yong Liu,
• Abstract summary: We show that Mamba can match Transformer performance in sequence modeling while significantly reducing computational costs.<n>We further analyze Mamba's ability to tackle Chain of Thought (CoT) tasks.<n>Our findings suggest that to solve arbitrary DP problems, the total cost of Mamba is still comparable to standard Transformers.
• Score: 9.024844892536327
• License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
• Abstract: Transformers have become the backbone of modern Large Language Models (LLMs); however, their inference overhead grows linearly with the sequence length, posing challenges for modeling long sequences. In light of this, Mamba has attracted attention for maintaining a constant inference size, with empirical evidence demonstrating that it can match Transformer performance in sequence modeling while significantly reducing computational costs. However, an open question remains: can Mamba always bring savings while achieving performance comparable to Transformers? In this paper, we focus on analyzing the expressive ability of Mamba to perform our defined COPY operation and Chain of Thought (CoT) reasoning. First, inspired by the connection between Mamba and linear attention, we show that constant-sized Mamba may struggle to perform COPY operations while Transformers can handle them more easily. However, when the size of Mamba grows linearly with the input sequence length, it can accurately perform COPY, but in this case, Mamba no longer provides overhead savings. Based on this observation, we further analyze Mamba's ability to tackle CoT tasks, which can be described by the Dynamic Programming (DP) problems. Our findings suggest that to solve arbitrary DP problems, the total cost of Mamba is still comparable to standard Transformers. However, similar to efficient Transformers, when facing DP problems with favorable properties such as locality, Mamba can provide savings in overhead. Our experiments on the copy and CoT tasks further demonstrate Mamba's limitations compared to Transformers in learning these tasks.

Related papers

• Differential Mamba [17.835292722130628]
  Sequence models like Transformers and RNNs often overallocate attention to irrelevant context, leading to noisy intermediate representations.<n>Recent work has shown that differential design can mitigate this issue in Transformers, improving their effectiveness across various applications.<n>We show that a naive adaptation of differential design to Mamba is insufficient and requires careful architectural modifications.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-07-08T17:30:14Z)
• Mamba meets crack segmentation [0.18416014644193066]
  Cracks pose safety risks to infrastructure and cannot be overlooked. CNNs exhibit a deficiency in global modeling capability, hindering the representation to entire crack features. This study explores the representation capabilities of Mamba to crack features.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-07-22T15:21:35Z)
• Speech Slytherin: Examining the Performance and Efficiency of Mamba for Speech Separation, Recognition, and Synthesis [18.68317727349427]
  It is too early to conclude that Mamba is a better alternative to transformers for speech. We evaluate three models for three tasks: Mamba-TasNet for speech separation, ConMamba for speech recognition, and VALL-M for speech synthesis.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-07-13T00:35:21Z)
• Snakes and Ladders: Two Steps Up for VideoMamba [10.954210339694841]
  In this paper, we theoretically analyze the differences between self-attention and Mamba. We propose VideoMambaPro models that surpass VideoMamba by 1.6-2.8% and 1.1-1.9% top-1. Our two solutions are to recent advances in Vision Mamba models, and are likely to provide further improvements in future models.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-06-27T08:45:31Z)
• Venturing into Uncharted Waters: The Navigation Compass from Transformer to Mamba [77.21394300708172]
  Transformer, a deep neural network architecture, has long dominated the field of natural language processing and beyond. The recent introduction of Mamba challenges its supremacy, sparks considerable interest among researchers, and gives rise to a series of Mamba-based models that have exhibited notable potential. This survey paper orchestrates a comprehensive discussion, diving into essential research dimensions, covering: (i) the functioning of the Mamba mechanism and its foundation on the principles of structured state space models; (ii) the proposed improvements and the integration of Mamba with various networks, exploring its potential as a substitute for Transformers; (iii) the combination of
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-06-24T15:27:21Z)
• DeciMamba: Exploring the Length Extrapolation Potential of Mamba [89.07242846058023]
  We introduce DeciMamba, a context-extension method specifically designed for Mamba. We show that DeciMamba can extrapolate context lengths 25x longer than the ones seen during training, and does so without utilizing additional computational resources.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-06-20T17:40:18Z)
• An Empirical Study of Mamba-based Language Models [69.74383762508805]
  Selective state-space models (SSMs) like Mamba overcome some shortcomings of Transformers. We present a direct comparison between 8B-context Mamba, Mamba-2, and Transformer models trained on the same datasets. We find that the 8B Mamba-2-Hybrid exceeds the 8B Transformer on all 12 standard tasks.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-06-12T05:25:15Z)
• Autoregressive Pretraining with Mamba in Vision [45.25546594814871]
  This paper shows that Mamba's visual capability can be significantly enhanced through autoregressive pretraining. Performance-wise, autoregressive pretraining equips the Mamba architecture with markedly higher accuracy. Our huge-size Mamba attains 85.0% ImageNet accuracy when finetuned with $384times384$ inputs.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-06-11T17:58:34Z)
• Demystify Mamba in Vision: A Linear Attention Perspective [72.93213667713493]
  Mamba is an effective state space model with linear computation complexity. We show that Mamba shares surprising similarities with linear attention Transformer. We propose a Mamba-Like Linear Attention (MLLA) model by incorporating the merits of these two key designs into linear attention.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-05-26T15:31:09Z)
• MambaOut: Do We Really Need Mamba for Vision? [70.60495392198686]
  Mamba, an architecture with RNN-like token mixer of state space model (SSM), was recently introduced to address the quadratic complexity of the attention mechanism. This paper conceptually concludes that Mamba is ideally suited for tasks with long-sequence and autoregressive characteristics. We construct a series of models named MambaOut through stacking Mamba blocks while removing their core token mixer, SSM.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-05-13T17:59:56Z)
• ReMamber: Referring Image Segmentation with Mamba Twister [51.291487576255435]
  ReMamber is a novel RIS architecture that integrates the power of Mamba with a multi-modal Mamba Twister block. The Mamba Twister explicitly models image-text interaction, and fuses textual and visual features through its unique channel and spatial twisting mechanism.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-03-26T16:27:37Z)
• Is Mamba Capable of In-Context Learning? [63.682741783013306]
  State of the art foundation models such as GPT-4 perform surprisingly well at in-context learning (ICL) This work provides empirical evidence that Mamba, a newly proposed state space model, has similar ICL capabilities.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-02-05T16:39:12Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.