The Role of the Retrospective Meetings in Detecting, Refactoring and Monitoring Community Smells

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2502.18662v1
• Date: Tue, 25 Feb 2025 21:50:13 GMT
• Title: The Role of the Retrospective Meetings in Detecting, Refactoring and Monitoring Community Smells
• Abstract summary: The study focused on the four most cited Community Smells in the literature -- Lone Wolf, Organizational Silo, Radio Silence, and Black Cloud.<n>The findings indicate that retrospective meetings indeed enable the identification of core Community Smells.<n>An emphasis on positive aspects during these meetings may help in preventing Community Smells.
• Score: 0.5219568203653523
• License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
• Abstract: Retrospective meetings play a vital role in agile development by facilitating team reflection on past work to enhance effectiveness. These meetings address various social aspects, including team dynamics, individual performance, processes, and technologies, ultimately leading to actions for improvement. Despite their importance, limited research has explored how these meetings handle forms of social debt, particularly Community Smells -- recurring dysfunctional patterns in team dynamics, such as poor communication or isolated work practices. This study seeks to understand how retrospective meetings address a few core Community Smells, examining whether these meetings help identify smells, make it possible to formulate refactoring strategies, support the monitoring of refactoring actions, and contribute to preventing the most prominent Community Smells. We conducted semi-structured interviews with 15 practitioners from diverse organizations who regularly participate in retrospective meetings. The interviewees shared their experiences with retrospectives, the challenges discussed, and subsequent improvement actions. The study focused on the four most cited Community Smells in the literature -- Lone Wolf, Organizational Silo, Radio Silence, and Black Cloud. Data was analyzed iteratively using a priori coding to examine Community Smells and inductive open coding inspired by Grounded Theory. The findings indicate that retrospective meetings indeed enable the identification of core Community Smells. However, while strategies for refactoring are often formulated, their implementation and monitoring remain inconsistent. Additionally, an emphasis on positive aspects during these meetings may help in preventing Community Smells. This study offers valuable insights to practitioners and researchers, highlighting the importance of addressing social debt in software development within agile practices.

Related papers

• Emergence of cooperation: A reputation-modulated reinforcement learning [19.357969561684982]
  Reputation is widely recognized as a key mechanism for sustaining cooperation.<n>We propose a spatial prisoner's dilemma game grounded in the reinforcement learning paradigm.<n>Our results reveal that reputation-modulated learning significantly promotes the emergence of cooperative behavior.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-08-20T13:27:41Z)
• Addressing OSS Community Managers' Challenges in Contributor Retention [17.01123608526415]
  Current tools for managing contributor retention (e.g., dashboards) fall short by providing retrospective rather than predictive insights to identify potential disengagement early.<n>Our study offers (1) empirical insights into the challenges of contributor retention management in OSS, (2) actionable strategies that support OSS community managers' retention efforts, and (3) a practical framework for future research in developing or validating theories about OSS sustainability.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-02-11T23:51:01Z)
• Part-Aware Bottom-Up Group Reasoning for Fine-Grained Social Interaction Detection [82.70752567211251]
  We propose a part-aware bottom-up group reasoning framework for fine-grained social interaction detection.<n>The proposed method infers social groups and their interactions using body part features and their interpersonal relations.<n>Our model first detects individuals and enhances their features using part-aware cues, and then infers group configuration by associating individuals via similarity-based reasoning.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-11-05T17:33:03Z)
• Exploring Engagement in Hybrid Meetings [5.975628871724407]
  The widespread adoption of hybrid work following the COVID-19 pandemic has transformed software development practices.<n>While remote participation in meetings has become commonplace, it may lead to isolation, alienation, and decreased engagement among remote team members.<n>This study aims to identify and characterize engagement patterns in hybrid meetings through objective measurements.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-09-25T06:07:02Z)
• In-person, Online and Back Again -- A Tale of Three Hybrid Hackathons [88.07897892705796]
  Hybrid hackathons combine in-person and online participation, presenting unique challenges for organizers and participants.<n>Existing strategies for in-person or online-only events often fail to address the challenges of hybrid formats.<n>Our work examines how hybrid hackathons function, analyzing how organizers structure these events and how participants navigate hybrid-specific challenges.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-08-10T11:27:01Z)
• How Do Communities of ML-Enabled Systems Smell? A Cross-Sectional Study on the Prevalence of Community Smells [13.840177755312665]
  We conducted an empirical study on 188 repositories from the NICHE dataset using the CADOCS tool to identify and analyze community smells. We found that certain smells, such as Prima Donna Effects and Sharing Villainy, are more prevalent and fluctuate over time compared to others like Radio Silence or Organizational Skirmish.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-04-24T10:23:37Z)
• A Survey of Efficient Reasoning for Large Reasoning Models: Language, Multimodality, and Beyond [88.5807076505261]
  Large Reasoning Models (LRMs) have demonstrated strong performance gains by scaling up the length of Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning during inference. A growing concern lies in their tendency to produce excessively long reasoning traces. This inefficiency introduces significant challenges for training, inference, and real-world deployment.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-03-27T15:36:30Z)
• In Prospect and Retrospect: Reflective Memory Management for Long-term Personalized Dialogue Agents [70.12342024019044]
  Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant progress in open-ended dialogue, yet their inability to retain and retrieve relevant information limits their effectiveness. We propose Reflective Memory Management (RMM), a novel mechanism for long-term dialogue agents, integrating forward- and backward-looking reflections. RMM shows more than 10% accuracy improvement over the baseline without memory management on the LongMemEval dataset.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-03-11T04:15:52Z)
• Exploring Retrospective Meeting Practices and the Use of Data in Agile Teams [43.16629507708997]
  This study explores barriers to project data utilization, including psychological safety concerns and the disconnect between data collection and meaningful integration of data into retrospective meetings.<n>Our findings confirm that although teams routinely collect project data, they seldom employ it systematically during retrospectives.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-02-05T19:33:53Z)
• MEETING DELEGATE: Benchmarking LLMs on Attending Meetings on Our Behalf [31.889028210500165]
  Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their strong capabilities in natural language generation and reasoning.<n>We develop a prototype LLM-powered meeting delegate system and create a benchmark using real meeting transcripts.<n>GPT-4/4o maintain balanced performance between active and cautious engagement strategies.<n> Gemini 1.5 Pro tends to be more cautious, while Gemini 1.5 Flash and Llama3-8B/70B display more active tendencies.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-02-05T16:25:43Z)
• Meta-Reflection: A Feedback-Free Reflection Learning Framework [57.14485943991588]
  We propose Meta-Reflection, a feedback-free reflection mechanism that requires only a single inference pass without external feedback.<n>Motivated by the human ability to remember and retrieve reflections from past experiences, Meta-Reflection integrates reflective insights into a codebook.<n>To thoroughly investigate and evaluate the practicality of Meta-Reflection in real-world scenarios, we introduce an industrial e-commerce benchmark named E-commerce Customer Intent Detection.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-12-18T12:20:04Z)
• Catalysts of Conversation: Examining Interaction Dynamics Between Topic Initiators and Commentors in Alzheimer's Disease Online Communities [5.628007112061016]
  This study investigated the user interaction dynamics within two large, popular Alzheimers Disease and Related Dementias (ADRD) online communities.<n>We found that active topic initiator engagement drives higher comment volumes.<n>Practical caregiving topics prompt more re-engagement of topic initiators, while emotional support topics attract more comments from other commentors.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-12-18T00:00:41Z)
• A Survey On Enhancing Reinforcement Learning in Complex Environments: Insights from Human and LLM Feedback [1.0359008237358598]
  This paper focuses on problems of two-folds: firstly, we focus on humans or an LLMs assistance, investigating the ways in which these entities may collaborate with the RL agent in order to foster optimal behavior and expedite learning; secondly, we delve into the research papers dedicated to addressing the intricacies of environments characterized by large observation space.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-11-20T15:52:03Z)
• LLM-Based Agent Society Investigation: Collaboration and Confrontation in Avalon Gameplay [55.12945794835791]
  Using Avalon as a testbed, we employ system prompts to guide LLM agents in gameplay. We propose a novel framework, tailored for Avalon, features a multi-agent system facilitating efficient communication and interaction. Results affirm the framework's effectiveness in creating adaptive agents and suggest LLM-based agents' potential in navigating dynamic social interactions.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-10-23T14:35:26Z)
• Co-Located Human-Human Interaction Analysis using Nonverbal Cues: A Survey [71.43956423427397]
  We aim to identify the nonverbal cues and computational methodologies resulting in effective performance. This survey differs from its counterparts by involving the widest spectrum of social phenomena and interaction settings. Some major observations are: the most often used nonverbal cue, computational method, interaction environment, and sensing approach are speaking activity, support vector machines, and meetings composed of 3-4 persons equipped with microphones and cameras, respectively.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-07-20T13:37:57Z)
• Ask-AC: An Initiative Advisor-in-the-Loop Actor-Critic Framework [41.04606578479283]
  We introduce a novel initiative advisor-in-the-loop actor-critic framework, termed as Ask-AC. At the heart of Ask-AC are two complementary components, namely action requester and adaptive state selector. Experimental results on both stationary and non-stationary environments demonstrate that the proposed framework significantly improves the learning efficiency of the agent.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-07-05T10:58:11Z)
• Seeing Differently, Acting Similarly: Imitation Learning with Heterogeneous Observations [126.78199124026398]
  In many real-world imitation learning tasks, the demonstrator and the learner have to act in different but full observation spaces. In this work, we model the above learning problem as Heterogeneous Observations Learning (HOIL) We propose the Importance Weighting with REjection (IWRE) algorithm based on the techniques of importance-weighting, learning with rejection, and active querying to solve the key challenge of occupancy measure matching.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-06-17T05:44:04Z)
• Deep reinforcement learning models the emergent dynamics of human cooperation [13.425401489679583]
  Experimental research has been unable to shed light on how social cognitive mechanisms contribute to the where and when of collective action. We leverage multi-agent deep reinforcement learning to model how a social-cognitive mechanism--specifically, the intrinsic motivation to achieve a good reputation--steers group behavior.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-03-08T18:58:40Z)
• Exploring Zero-Shot Emergent Communication in Embodied Multi-Agent Populations [59.608216900601384]
  We study agents that learn to communicate via actuating their joints in a 3D environment. We show that under realistic assumptions, a non-uniform distribution of intents and a common-knowledge energy cost, these agents can find protocols that generalize to novel partners.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-10-29T19:23:10Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.