How to Train Your Robots? The Impact of Demonstration Modality on Imitation Learning

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2503.07017v1
• Date: Mon, 10 Mar 2025 07:57:26 GMT
• Title: How to Train Your Robots? The Impact of Demonstration Modality on Imitation Learning
• Authors: Haozhuo Li, Yuchen Cui, Dorsa Sadigh,
• Abstract summary: Imitation learning is a promising approach for learning robot policies with user-provided data.<n>We compare low-cost demonstration modalities including kinesthetic teaching, teleoperation with a VR controller, and teleoperation with a spacemouse controller.<n>Our results show that kinesthetic teaching is rated the most intuitive for controlling the robot and provides cleanest data for best downstream learning performance.
• Score: 25.798669976935283
• License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
• Abstract: Imitation learning is a promising approach for learning robot policies with user-provided data. The way demonstrations are provided, i.e., demonstration modality, influences the quality of the data. While existing research shows that kinesthetic teaching (physically guiding the robot) is preferred by users for the intuitiveness and ease of use, the majority of existing manipulation datasets were collected through teleoperation via a VR controller or spacemouse. In this work, we investigate how different demonstration modalities impact downstream learning performance as well as user experience. Specifically, we compare low-cost demonstration modalities including kinesthetic teaching, teleoperation with a VR controller, and teleoperation with a spacemouse controller. We experiment with three table-top manipulation tasks with different motion constraints. We evaluate and compare imitation learning performance using data from different demonstration modalities, and collected subjective feedback on user experience. Our results show that kinesthetic teaching is rated the most intuitive for controlling the robot and provides cleanest data for best downstream learning performance. However, it is not preferred as the way for large-scale data collection due to the physical load. Based on such insight, we propose a simple data collection scheme that relies on a small number of kinesthetic demonstrations mixed with data collected through teleoperation to achieve the best overall learning performance while maintaining low data-collection effort.

Related papers

• VITAL: Visual Teleoperation to Enhance Robot Learning through Human-in-the-Loop Corrections [10.49712834719005]
  We propose a low-cost visual teleoperation system for bimanual manipulation tasks, called VITAL. Our approach leverages affordable hardware and visual processing techniques to collect demonstrations. We enhance the generalizability and robustness of the learned policies by utilizing both real and simulated environments.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-07-30T23:29:47Z)
• AdaDemo: Data-Efficient Demonstration Expansion for Generalist Robotic Agent [75.91274222142079]
  In this study, we aim to scale up demonstrations in a data-efficient way to facilitate the learning of generalist robotic agents. AdaDemo is a framework designed to improve multi-task policy learning by actively and continually expanding the demonstration dataset.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-04-11T01:59:29Z)
• Any-point Trajectory Modeling for Policy Learning [64.23861308947852]
  We introduce Any-point Trajectory Modeling (ATM) to predict future trajectories of arbitrary points within a video frame. ATM outperforms strong video pre-training baselines by 80% on average. We show effective transfer learning of manipulation skills from human videos and videos from a different robot morphology.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-12-28T23:34:43Z)
• Self-Improving Robots: End-to-End Autonomous Visuomotor Reinforcement Learning [54.636562516974884]
  In imitation and reinforcement learning, the cost of human supervision limits the amount of data that robots can be trained on. In this work, we propose MEDAL++, a novel design for self-improving robotic systems. The robot autonomously practices the task by learning to both do and undo the task, simultaneously inferring the reward function from the demonstrations.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-03-02T18:51:38Z)
• Continual Learning from Demonstration of Robotics Skills [5.573543601558405]
  Methods for teaching motion skills to robots focus on training for a single skill at a time. We propose an approach for continual learning from demonstration using hypernetworks and neural ordinary differential equation solvers.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-02-14T16:26:52Z)
• Playful Interactions for Representation Learning [82.59215739257104]
  We propose to use playful interactions in a self-supervised manner to learn visual representations for downstream tasks. We collect 2 hours of playful data in 19 diverse environments and use self-predictive learning to extract visual representations. Our representations generalize better than standard behavior cloning and can achieve similar performance with only half the number of required demonstrations.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-07-19T17:54:48Z)
• Learning from Imperfect Demonstrations from Agents with Varying Dynamics [29.94164262533282]
  We develop a metric composed of a feasibility score and an optimality score to measure how useful a demonstration is for imitation learning. Our experiments on four environments in simulation and on a real robot show improved learned policies with higher expected return.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-03-10T07:39:38Z)
• Visual Imitation Made Easy [102.36509665008732]
  We present an alternate interface for imitation that simplifies the data collection process while allowing for easy transfer to robots. We use commercially available reacher-grabber assistive tools both as a data collection device and as the robot's end-effector. We experimentally evaluate on two challenging tasks: non-prehensile pushing and prehensile stacking, with 1000 diverse demonstrations for each task.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-08-11T17:58:50Z)
• Learning Predictive Models From Observation and Interaction [137.77887825854768]
  Learning predictive models from interaction with the world allows an agent, such as a robot, to learn about how the world works. However, learning a model that captures the dynamics of complex skills represents a major challenge. We propose a method to augment the training set with observational data of other agents, such as humans.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2019-12-30T01:10:41Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.