Is the existence of unbounded operators a problem for quantum mechanics? In response to Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2603.10601v1
• Date: Wed, 11 Mar 2026 09:54:52 GMT
• Title: Is the existence of unbounded operators a problem for quantum mechanics? In response to Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala
• Abstract summary: I argue against Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala's recent claim that the Hilbert spaces are unphysical.<n>I argue that the existence of infinite expectation values does not cause problems in quantum mechanics.
• Score: 0.27689558531442177
• License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
• Abstract: In this paper I argue against Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala's recent claim that the Hilbert spaces are unphysical and should be replaced with the Schwartz spaces in quantum mechanics, since Hilbert spaces include states with infinite expectation values for certain observables. I also review and discuss issues regarding unbounded operators in quantum mechanics raised by Streater and Wightman, Heathcote, and Lemos. I argue that the existence of infinite expectation values does not cause problems in quantum mechanics. On the other hand, replacing the Hilbert spaces with the Schwartz spaces would cause more issues, as it would exclude a class of meaningful Hamiltonian evolutions. I also discuss the question in literature whether reformulating quantum mechanics with essentially self-adjoint operators instead of self-adjoint operators may cause problems. I further analyse the hierarchies of the notions of "physicality" and possibility in fundamental physics, and suggest that "physicality" is a vague concept. Finally, I connect the problem raised by Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala with the problem of the Hadamard condition in quantum field theory.

Related papers

• Quantum Mechanics: Problems and Paradoxes [41.99844472131922]
  This book examines a number of problems of quantum mechanics, most of which are not usually discussed.<n>For advanced undergraduate students, graduate students, and specialists interested in the foundations of quantum theory.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-05-28T15:15:27Z)
• Solving the Mysteries of Quantum Mechanics: Why Nature Abhors a Continuum [0.0]
  We develop a theory of quantum physics in which Hilbert Space is gravitationally discretised.<n>The key to solving the mysteries of QM in RaQM is a number-theoretic property of the cosine function.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-02-18T11:41:09Z)
• "It from Bit": The Hartle-Hawking state and quantum mechanics for de Sitter observers [8.482707797354104]
  We argue that the one-state property of closed universes is fully compatible with the finite-dimensional quantum mechanics experienced by observers inside de Sitter space.<n>We show that the quantum mechanics experienced by an observer inside de Sitter space emerges from the classical statistics encoded in the baby-universe Hilbert space.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-02-05T17:50:15Z)
• Will we ever quantize the center of mass of macroscopic systems? A case for a Heisenberg cut in quantum mechanics [0.0]
  The concept of quantum particles derives from quantum field theory.<n>Wave mechanics can describe the center of mass of systems at or above the Planck scale.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-01-28T12:03:26Z)
• Towards entropic uncertainty relations for non-regular Hilbert spaces [44.99833362998488]
  The Entropic Uncertainty Relations (EUR) result from inequalities that are intrinsic to the Hilbert space and its dual with no direct connection to the Canonical Commutation Relations.<n>The analysis of these EUR in the context of singular Hilbert spaces has not been addressed.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-03-24T23:41:50Z)
• A healthier stochastic semiclassical gravity: world without Schrödinger cats [0.0]
  Semiclassical gravity couples classical gravity to the quantized matter in meanfield approximation.<n>Meanfield coupling is problematic for two reasons. First, it ignores the quantum fluctuation of matter distribution.<n>Second, it violates the linearity of the quantum dynamics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-01-30T17:03:38Z)
• Superstate Quantum Mechanics [35.18016233072556]
  We introduce Superstate Quantum Mechanics (SQM) as a theory that considers states in Hilbert space subject to multiple quadratic constraints.<n>In this case, the stationary SQM problem is a quantum inverse problem with multiple applications in physics, machine learning, and artificial intelligence.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-01-25T19:41:04Z)
• Are Hilbert Spaces Unphysical? Hardly, My Dear! [0.0]
  It is widely accepted that the states of any quantum system are vectors in a Hilbert space.<n>This paper seeks to pinpoint supposedly unsurmountable difficulties inherent in postulating that the physical states are elements of a Hilbert space.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-01-06T10:55:32Z)
• Primer on quantum weirdness [0.0]
  We assume knowledge of basic quantum mechanics.<n>We explicate ideas as projectors, density operators, Bell inequalities, entanglement and the Lindblad equation.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-08-13T18:06:02Z)
• Ruling out real-valued standard formalism of quantum theory [19.015836913247288]
  A quantum game has been developed to distinguish standard quantum theory from its real-number analog. We experimentally implement the quantum game based on entanglement swapping with a state-of-the-art fidelity of 0.952(1). Our results disprove the real-number formulation and establish the indispensable role of complex numbers in the standard quantum theory.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-03-15T03:56:13Z)
• Are quantum cryptographic security claims vacuous? [12.970250708769708]
  We explain why Bernstein's reasoning is based on a too "classical" understanding of physics. It follows from known theorems about fault-tolerant quantum computation that quantum physics avoids his conclusion.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-10-22T18:00:05Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.