Comment on "Quantum theory based on real numbers cannot be experimentally falsified": On the compatibility of physical principles with information theory for fermions

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2604.07425v1
• Date: Wed, 08 Apr 2026 17:10:22 GMT
• Title: Comment on "Quantum theory based on real numbers cannot be experimentally falsified": On the compatibility of physical principles with information theory for fermions
• Abstract summary: We make the claim that a general physical postulate should in particular be satisfied by Fermionic Information Theory (FIT), the standard framework describing information encoded in the presence or absence of identical fermions.<n>We show that this postulate proposed by [arXiv:2603.19208] fails in FIT, hence is not a general physical postulate according to our claim.
• Score: 1.1470070927586018
• License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
• Abstract: The manuscript [arXiv:2603.19208] proposes a physically motivated postulate to select the appropriate formulation of quantum theory over real Hilbert spaces, ruling out the theory considered in [Nature 600, 625-629 (2021)] in favour of the alternative theory which reproduces the predictions of standard quantum information theory (QIT). Here, we first make the claim that a general physical postulate should in particular be satisfied by Fermionic Information Theory (FIT), the standard framework describing information encoded in the presence or absence of identical fermions. We then show that this postulate proposed by [arXiv:2603.19208] fails in FIT, hence is not a general physical postulate according to our claim. More broadly, our results highlight the importance of confronting proposed foundational principles with fermionic information theories, a point that also deserves further examination in recent related works such as [arXiv:2503.17307] and [arXiv:2504.02808].

Related papers

• Derivation of Standard Quantum Theory via State Discrimination [53.64687146666141]
  General Probabilistic Theories (GPTs) is a new information theoretical approach to single out standard quantum theory. We focus on the bound of the performance for an information task called state discrimination in general models. We characterize standard quantum theory out of general models in GPTs by the bound of the performance for state discrimination.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-07-21T00:02:11Z)
• Connecting classical finite exchangeability to quantum theory [45.76759085727843]
  Exchangeability is a fundamental concept in probability theory and statistics.<n>It allows to model situations where the order of observations does not matter.<n>It is well known that both theorems do not hold for finitely exchangeable sequences.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-06-06T17:15:19Z)
• Quantum Theory Needs (And Probably Has) Real Reduction [0.0]
  It appears that for quantum theory to be viable in a realist sense, it must possess genuine, physical non-unitarity. Penrose's theory of gravitation-induced collapse and the Transactional Interpretation are discussed.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-04-20T21:25:23Z)
• Testing quantum theory by generalizing noncontextuality [0.0]
  We prove that only Jordan-algebraic state spaces are exactly embeddable into quantum theory. We propose an experimental test of quantum theory by probing single physical systems.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-12-17T19:00:24Z)
• Gentle Measurement as a Principle of Quantum Theory [9.137554315375919]
  We propose the gentle measurement principle (GMP) as one of the principles at the foundation of quantum mechanics. We show, within the framework of general probabilistic theories, that GMP imposes strong restrictions on the law of physics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-03-28T11:59:49Z)
• Entanglement and Complexity of Purification in (1+1)-dimensional free Conformal Field Theories [55.53519491066413]
  We find pure states in an enlarged Hilbert space that encode the mixed state of a quantum field theory as a partial trace. We analyze these quantities for two intervals in the vacuum of free bosonic and Ising conformal field theories.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-09-24T18:00:13Z)
• Measuring Quantum Superpositions (Or, "It is only the theory which decides what can be observed.") [0.0]
  We argue that the ad hoc introduction of the projection postulate (or measurement rule) can be understood as a necessary requirement coming from a naive empiricist standpoint. We discuss the general physical conditions for measuring and observing quantum superpositions.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-07-02T14:30:56Z)
• General Probabilistic Theories with a Gleason-type Theorem [0.0]
  Gleason-type theorems for quantum theory allow one to recover the quantum state space. We identify the class of general probabilistic theories which also admit Gleason-type theorems.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-05-28T17:29:29Z)
• Perfect Discrimination in Approximate Quantum Theory of General Probabilistic Theories [51.7367238070864]
  We define larger measurement classes that are smoothly connected with the class of POVMs via a parameter. We give a sufficient condition of perfect discrimination, which shows a significant improvement beyond the class of POVMs.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-04-10T08:45:20Z)
• From a quantum theory to a classical one [117.44028458220427]
  We present and discuss a formal approach for describing the quantum to classical crossover. The method was originally introduced by L. Yaffe in 1982 for tackling large-$N$ quantum field theories.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-04-01T09:16:38Z)
• Quantum Mechanical description of Bell's experiment assumes Locality [91.3755431537592]
  Bell's experiment description assumes the (Quantum Mechanics-language equivalent of the classical) condition of Locality. This result is complementary to a recently published one demonstrating that non-Locality is necessary to describe said experiment. It is concluded that, within the framework of Quantum Mechanics, there is absolutely no reason to believe in the existence of non-Local effects.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-02-27T15:04:08Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.