How Quantum Is the Advantage? A Fair, Calibration- and Noise-Aware Benchmark and Attribution Audit of Quantum Machine Learning for Network Intrusion Detection

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2608.18155v1
• Date: Thu, 13 Aug 2026 07:44:35 GMT
• Title: How Quantum Is the Advantage? A Fair, Calibration- and Noise-Aware Benchmark and Attribution Audit of Quantum Machine Learning for Network Intrusion Detection
• Abstract summary: Quantum machine learning for network intrusion detection is routinely reported to reach near-perfect accuracy.<n>Most rigorous studies find that well-tuned classical models remain competitive.<n>We present a unified, reproducible QML-IDS benchmark evaluating hybrid variational quantum circuits.
• Score: 0.0
• License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
• Abstract: Quantum machine learning (QML) for network intrusion detection (NIDS) is routinely reported to reach near-perfect accuracy, yet the most rigorous studies find that well-tuned classical models remain competitive, and that apparent quantum gains may be artefacts of classical dimensionality reduction and implicit regularisation rather than genuine quantum effects. We ask not whether a quantum model can post a high accuracy, but how quantum the advantage really is. We present a unified, reproducible QML-IDS benchmark evaluating hybrid variational quantum circuits and quantum-kernel SVMs against five honestly-tuned classical baselines across four standard NIDS datasets (NSL-KDD, UNSW-NB15, CICIDS2017, NF-ToN-IoT-v2) under one leakage-controlled protocol, with an equal-budget feature view, imbalance- and calibration-aware metrics with significance testing, and a simulated NISQ noise sweep. We introduce a quantum-attribution audit (parameter-matched classical controls, a random-feature kernel, and a regularisation sweep) that quantifies how much of any gain is genuinely attributable to the quantum component. Tuned classical models (Random Forest, XGBoost) match or exceed the quantum models on aggregate detection on every dataset, and the audit attributes this to classical preprocessing and regularisation rather than quantum effects. Two advantages survive false-discovery-rate correction: the quantum-kernel SVM out-ranks its direct classical surrogate (a random-feature kernel) on AUPRC and ROC-AUC, and a small four-qubit hybrid out-detects the best classical baseline at the 1% false-positive operating point on the distribution-shifted NSL-KDD task (p = 0.005, BH q = 0.030). Code, seeds, and splits are released; our contribution stands whether quantum wins, ties, or loses.

Related papers

• Adversarial Limits of Quantum Certification: When Eve Defeats Detection [0.0]
  Security of quantum key distribution relies on certifying that observed correlations arise from genuine quantum entanglement.<n>Eve GAN is a generative adversarial network trained to produce classical correlations indistinguishable from quantum.<n>We find that same distribution calibration a common practice in prior certification studies inflates detection performance by 44 percentage points.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-12-04T02:24:04Z)
• Hybrid Quantum-Classical Learning of Nonlinear Entanglement Witnesses via Continuous-Variable Quantum Neural Networks [0.0]
  We introduce a hybrid quantum-classical framework that learns a nonlinear entanglement witness directly from quantum data using continuous-variable quantum neural networks (CV-QNNs)<n>Our architecture combines variational interferometers, squeezers and non-Gaussian Kerr gates with a small classical neural head to output a scalar witness value.<n>We show that when the quantum measurement stage is informationally complete, the hybrid model can approximate any continuous witness-like functional on compact sets of states.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-09-07T04:45:59Z)
• VQC-MLPNet: An Unconventional Hybrid Quantum-Classical Architecture for Scalable and Robust Quantum Machine Learning [50.95799256262098]
  Variational quantum circuits (VQCs) hold promise for quantum machine learning but face challenges in expressivity, trainability, and noise resilience.<n>We propose VQC-MLPNet, a hybrid architecture where a VQC generates the first-layer weights of a classical multilayer perceptron during training, while inference is performed entirely classically.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-06-12T01:38:15Z)
• Toward Practical Quantum Machine Learning: A Novel Hybrid Quantum LSTM for Fraud Detection [0.1398098625978622]
  We present a novel hybrid quantum-classical neural network architecture for fraud detection.<n>By leveraging quantum phenomena such as superposition and entanglement, our model enhances the feature representation of sequential transaction data.<n>Results demonstrate competitive improvements in accuracy, precision, recall, and F1 score relative to a conventional LSTM baseline.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-04-30T19:09:12Z)
• Quantum phase classification via quantum hypothesis testing [0.39102514525861415]
  We propose a classification algorithm based on the quantum Neyman-Pearson test, which is theoretically optimal for distinguishing between two quantum states.<n>Our results show that the proposed method achieves lower classification error probabilities and significantly reduces the training cost.<n>These findings highlight the potential of quantum hypothesis testing as a powerful tool for quantum phase classification.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-04-05T08:23:45Z)
• A Quantum-Classical Collaborative Training Architecture Based on Quantum State Fidelity [50.387179833629254]
  We introduce a collaborative classical-quantum architecture called co-TenQu. Co-TenQu enhances a classical deep neural network by up to 41.72% in a fair setting. It outperforms other quantum-based methods by up to 1.9 times and achieves similar accuracy while utilizing 70.59% fewer qubits.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-02-23T14:09:41Z)
• Mitigating Errors on Superconducting Quantum Processors through Fuzzy Clustering [38.02852247910155]
  A new Quantum Error Mitigation (QEM) technique uses Fuzzy C-Means clustering to specifically identify measurement error patterns. We report a proof-of-principle validation of the technique on a 2-qubit register, obtained as a subset of a real NISQ 5-qubit superconducting quantum processor. We demonstrate that the FCM-based QEM technique allows for reasonable improvement of the expectation values of single- and two-qubit gates based quantum circuits.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-02-02T14:02:45Z)
• QuantumSEA: In-Time Sparse Exploration for Noise Adaptive Quantum Circuits [82.50620782471485]
  QuantumSEA is an in-time sparse exploration for noise-adaptive quantum circuits. It aims to achieve two key objectives: (1) implicit circuits capacity during training and (2) noise robustness. Our method establishes state-of-the-art results with only half the number of quantum gates and 2x time saving of circuit executions.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-01-10T22:33:00Z)
• Classical Verification of Quantum Learning [42.362388367152256]
  We develop a framework for classical verification of quantum learning. We propose a new quantum data access model that we call "mixture-of-superpositions" quantum examples. Our results demonstrate that the potential power of quantum data for learning tasks, while not unlimited, can be utilized by classical agents.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-06-08T00:31:27Z)
• QuanGCN: Noise-Adaptive Training for Robust Quantum Graph Convolutional Networks [124.7972093110732]
  We propose quantum graph convolutional networks (QuanGCN), which learns the local message passing among nodes with the sequence of crossing-gate quantum operations. To mitigate the inherent noises from modern quantum devices, we apply sparse constraint to sparsify the nodes' connections. Our QuanGCN is functionally comparable or even superior than the classical algorithms on several benchmark graph datasets.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-11-09T21:43:16Z)
• On the learnability of quantum neural networks [132.1981461292324]
  We consider the learnability of the quantum neural network (QNN) built on the variational hybrid quantum-classical scheme. We show that if a concept can be efficiently learned by QNN, then it can also be effectively learned by QNN even with gate noise.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-07-24T06:34:34Z)
• Quantum noise protects quantum classifiers against adversaries [120.08771960032033]
  Noise in quantum information processing is often viewed as a disruptive and difficult-to-avoid feature, especially in near-term quantum technologies. We show that by taking advantage of depolarisation noise in quantum circuits for classification, a robustness bound against adversaries can be derived. This is the first quantum protocol that can be used against the most general adversaries.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-03-20T17:56:14Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.