Maxwell's Demon Is Foiled by the Entropy Cost of Measurement, Not Erasure

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2503.18186v1
• Date: Sun, 23 Mar 2025 19:49:12 GMT
• Title: Maxwell's Demon Is Foiled by the Entropy Cost of Measurement, Not Erasure
• Authors: R. E. Kastner,
• Abstract summary: conventional claim that the second law of thermodynamics is saved from a "Maxwell's Demon" by the entropy cost of information erasure.<n>I argue that the fundamental principle that saves the second law is the quantum uncertainty principle.<n>I obtain the specific entropy cost for localizing a molecule in the Szilard engine.
• Score: 0.0
• License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
• Abstract: I dispute the conventional claim that the second law of thermodynamics is saved from a "Maxwell's Demon" by the entropy cost of information erasure, and show that instead it is measurement that incurs the entropy cost. Thus Brillouin, who identified measurement as savior of the second law, was essentially correct, and putative refutations of his view, such as Bennett's claim to measure without entropy cost, are seen to fail when the applicable physics is taken into account. I argue that the tradition of attributing the defeat of Maxwell's Demon to erasure rather than to measurement arose from unphysical classical idealizations that do not hold for real gas molecules, as well as a physically ungrounded recasting of physical thermodynamical processes into computational and information-theoretic conceptualizations. I argue that the fundamental principle that saves the second law is the quantum uncertainty principle applying to the need to localize physical states to precise values of observables in order to effect the desired disequilibria aimed at violating the second law. I obtain the specific entropy cost for localizing a molecule in the Szilard engine, which coincides with the quantity attributed to Landauer's principle. I also note that an experiment characterized as upholding an entropy cost of erasure in a "quantum Maxwell's Demon" actually demonstrates an entropy cost of measurement.

Related papers

• Generalized Quantum Stein's Lemma and Second Law of Quantum Resource Theories [47.02222405817297]
  A fundamental question in quantum information theory is whether an analogous second law can be formulated to characterize the convertibility of resources for quantum information processing by a single function. In 2008, a promising formulation was proposed, linking resource convertibility to the optimal performance of a variant of the quantum version of hypothesis testing. In 2023, a logical gap was found in the original proof of this lemma, casting doubt on the possibility of such a formulation of the second law.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-08-05T18:00:00Z)
• Comment on "Extending the Laws of Thermodynamics for Arbitrary Autonomous Quantum Systems" [0.0]
  Recently, Elouard and Lombard Latune claimed to extend the laws of thermodynamics to "arbitrary quantum systems" valid "at any scale" I show that their definitions are in conflict with textbook thermodynamics and over- or underestimate the real entropy production by orders of magnitude.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-09-08T07:30:45Z)
• Universal validity of the second law of information thermodynamics [1.8641315013048299]
  We characterize the full range of quantum feedback control and erasure protocols that are consistent with the second law of thermodynamics.<n>This leads us to conclude that the second law of information thermodynamics is indeed universal.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-08-29T18:24:36Z)
• Coherence manipulation in asymmetry and thermodynamics [44.99833362998488]
  In the classical regime, thermodynamic state transformations are governed by the free energy.<n>In the quantum regime, coherence and free energy are two independent resources.<n>We show that allowing along with a source of free energy allows us to amplify any quantum coherence present in the quantum state arbitrarily.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-08-24T14:18:19Z)
• Testing the Quantum of Entropy [0.0]
  It is clarified when it is possible to speak about a quantum of entropy, given by the Boltzmann constant k, and about a lower entropy limit $S geq k ln 2$.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-07-19T11:34:54Z)
• Noncommuting conserved charges in quantum thermodynamics and beyond [39.781091151259766]
  How do noncommuting charges affect thermodynamic phenomena? Charges' noncommutation has been found to invalidate derivations of the thermal state's form. Evidence suggests that noncommuting charges may hinder thermalization in some ways while enhancing thermalization in others.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-05-31T18:00:00Z)
• Inevitability of knowing less than nothing [5.767156832161818]
  In the classical world, entropy and conditional entropy take only non-negative values. We introduce a physically motivated framework for defining quantum conditional entropy.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-08-30T17:44:17Z)
• Gauge Quantum Thermodynamics of Time-local non-Markovian Evolutions [77.34726150561087]
  We deal with a generic time-local non-Markovian master equation. We define current and power to be process-dependent as in classical thermodynamics. Applying the theory to quantum thermal engines, we show that gauge transformations can change the machine efficiency.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-04-06T17:59:15Z)
• Maximum entropy quantum state distributions [58.720142291102135]
  We go beyond traditional thermodynamics and condition on the full distribution of the conserved quantities. The result are quantum state distributions whose deviations from thermal states' get more pronounced in the limit of wide input distributions.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-03-23T17:42:34Z)
• Open-system approach to nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics at arbitrary coupling [77.34726150561087]
  We develop a general theory describing the thermodynamical behavior of open quantum systems coupled to thermal baths. Our approach is based on the exact time-local quantum master equation for the reduced open system states.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-09-24T11:19:22Z)
• Catalytic Transformations of Pure Entangled States [62.997667081978825]
  Entanglement entropy is the von Neumann entropy of quantum entanglement of pure states. The relation between entanglement entropy and entanglement distillation has been known only for the setting, and the meaning of entanglement entropy in the single-copy regime has so far remained open. Our results imply that entanglement entropy quantifies the amount of entanglement available in a bipartite pure state to be used for quantum information processing, giving results an operational meaning also in entangled single-copy setup.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-02-22T16:05:01Z)
• Probabilistically Violating the First Law of Thermodynamics in a Quantum Heat Engine [0.0]
  We show that in the presence of quantum fluctuations, the first law of thermodynamics may break down. This happens because quantum mechanics imposes constraints on the knowledge of heat and work. Our results imply that in the presence of quantum fluctuations, the first law of thermodynamics may not be applicable to individual experimental runs.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-02-02T09:23:21Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.