Towards Training-Free Underwater 3D Object Detection from Sonar Point Clouds: A Comparison of Traditional and Deep Learning Approaches

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2508.18293v1
• Date: Fri, 22 Aug 2025 12:08:21 GMT
• Title: Towards Training-Free Underwater 3D Object Detection from Sonar Point Clouds: A Comparison of Traditional and Deep Learning Approaches
• Authors: M. Salman Shaukat, Yannik Käckenmeister, Sebastian Bader, Thomas Kirste,
• Abstract summary: We develop and compare two paradigms for training-free detection of artificial structures in multibeam echo-sounder point clouds.<n>Our dual approach combines a physics-based sonar simulation pipeline that generates synthetic training data for state-of-the-art neural networks, with a robust model-based template matching system.<n>Our findings challenge conventional wisdom about data-hungry deep learning in underwater domains and establish the first large-scale benchmark for training-free underwater 3D detection.
• Score: 0.0
• License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
• Abstract: Underwater 3D object detection remains one of the most challenging frontiers in computer vision, where traditional approaches struggle with the harsh acoustic environment and scarcity of training data. While deep learning has revolutionized terrestrial 3D detection, its application underwater faces a critical bottleneck: obtaining sufficient annotated sonar data is prohibitively expensive and logistically complex, often requiring specialized vessels, expert surveyors, and favorable weather conditions. This work addresses a fundamental question: Can we achieve reliable underwater 3D object detection without real-world training data? We tackle this challenge by developing and comparing two paradigms for training-free detection of artificial structures in multibeam echo-sounder point clouds. Our dual approach combines a physics-based sonar simulation pipeline that generates synthetic training data for state-of-the-art neural networks, with a robust model-based template matching system that leverages geometric priors of target objects. Evaluation on real bathymetry surveys from the Baltic Sea reveals surprising insights: while neural networks trained on synthetic data achieve 98% mean Average Precision (mAP) on simulated scenes, they drop to 40% mAP on real sonar data due to domain shift. Conversely, our template matching approach maintains 83% mAP on real data without requiring any training, demonstrating remarkable robustness to acoustic noise and environmental variations. Our findings challenge conventional wisdom about data-hungry deep learning in underwater domains and establish the first large-scale benchmark for training-free underwater 3D detection. This work opens new possibilities for autonomous underwater vehicle navigation, marine archaeology, and offshore infrastructure monitoring in data-scarce environments where traditional machine learning approaches fail.

Related papers

• From Seeing to Experiencing: Scaling Navigation Foundation Models with Reinforcement Learning [59.88543114325153]
  We introduce the Seeing-to-Experiencing framework to scale the capability of navigation foundation models with reinforcement learning.<n>S2E combines the strengths of pre-training on videos and post-training through RL.<n>We establish a comprehensive end-to-end evaluation benchmark, NavBench-GS, built on photorealistic 3DGS reconstructions of real-world scenes.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-07-29T17:26:10Z)
• Topology-Aware Modeling for Unsupervised Simulation-to-Reality Point Cloud Recognition [63.55828203989405]
  We introduce a novel Topology-Aware Modeling (TAM) framework for Sim2Real UDA on object point clouds.<n>Our approach mitigates the domain gap by leveraging global spatial topology, characterized by low-level, high-frequency 3D structures.<n>We propose an advanced self-training strategy that combines cross-domain contrastive learning with self-training.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-06-26T11:53:59Z)
• Efficient Self-Supervised Learning for Earth Observation via Dynamic Dataset Curation [67.23953699167274]
  Self-supervised learning (SSL) has enabled the development of vision foundation models for Earth Observation (EO)<n>In EO, this challenge is amplified by the redundancy and heavy-tailed distributions common in satellite imagery.<n>We propose a dynamic dataset pruning strategy designed to improve SSL pre-training by maximizing dataset diversity and balance.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-04-09T15:13:26Z)
• Simulation-informed deep learning for enhanced SWOT observations of fine-scale ocean dynamics [4.575524892161048]
  Ocean processes at fine scales are crucial yet difficult to observe accurately due to limitations in satellite and in-situ measurements.<n>Current methods struggle with noisy data or require extensive supervised training, limiting their effectiveness on real-world observations.<n>We introduce SIMPGEN, an unsupervised adversarial learning framework combining real SWOT observations with simulated reference data.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-03-27T09:29:33Z)
• Sonar-based Deep Learning in Underwater Robotics: Overview, Robustness and Challenges [0.46873264197900916]
  The predominant use of sonar in underwater environments, characterized by limited training data and inherent noise, poses challenges to model robustness.<n>This paper studies sonar-based perception task models, such as classification, object detection, segmentation, and SLAM.<n>It systematizes sonar-based state-of-the-art datasets, simulators, and robustness methods such as neural network verification, out-of-distribution, and adversarial attacks.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-12-16T15:03:08Z)
• A Practical Approach to Underwater Depth and Surface Normals Estimation [3.0516727053033392]
  This paper presents a novel deep learning model for Monocular Depth and Surface Normals Estimation (MDSNE)<n>It is specifically tailored for underwater environments, using a hybrid architecture that integrates CNNs with Transformers.<n>Our model reduces parameters by 90% and training costs by 80%, allowing real-time 3D perception on resource-constrained devices.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-10-02T22:41:12Z)
• FAFA: Frequency-Aware Flow-Aided Self-Supervision for Underwater Object Pose Estimation [65.01601309903971]
  We introduce FAFA, a Frequency-Aware Flow-Aided self-supervised framework for 6D pose estimation of unmanned underwater vehicles (UUVs) Our framework relies solely on the 3D model and RGB images, alleviating the need for any real pose annotations or other-modality data like depths. We evaluate the effectiveness of FAFA on common underwater object pose benchmarks and showcase significant performance improvements compared to state-of-the-art methods.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-09-25T03:54:01Z)
• Scale-Translation Equivariant Network for Oceanic Internal Solitary Wave Localization [7.444865250744234]
  Internal solitary waves (ISWs) are gravity waves that are often observed in the interior ocean rather than the surface. Cloud cover in optical remote sensing images variably obscures ground information, leading to blurred or missing surface observations. This paper aims at altimeter-based machine learning solutions to automatically locate ISWs.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-06-18T21:09:56Z)
• Motion Degeneracy in Self-supervised Learning of Elevation Angle Estimation for 2D Forward-Looking Sonar [4.683630397028384]
  This study aims to realize stable self-supervised learning of elevation angle estimation without pretraining using synthetic images. We first analyze the motion field of 2D forward-looking sonar, which is related to the main supervision signal.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-07-30T08:06:11Z)
• DeepAqua: Self-Supervised Semantic Segmentation of Wetland Surface Water Extent with SAR Images using Knowledge Distillation [44.99833362998488]
  We present DeepAqua, a self-supervised deep learning model that eliminates the need for manual annotations during the training phase. We exploit cases where optical- and radar-based water masks coincide, enabling the detection of both open and vegetated water surfaces. Experimental results show that DeepAqua outperforms other unsupervised methods by improving accuracy by 7%, Intersection Over Union by 27%, and F1 score by 14%.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-05-02T18:06:21Z)
• An evaluation of deep learning models for predicting water depth evolution in urban floods [59.31940764426359]
  We compare different deep learning models for prediction of water depth at high spatial resolution. Deep learning models are trained to reproduce the data simulated by the CADDIES cellular-automata flood model. Our results show that the deep learning models present in general lower errors compared to the other methods.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-02-20T16:08:54Z)
• What Stops Learning-based 3D Registration from Working in the Real World? [53.68326201131434]
  This work identifies the sources of 3D point cloud registration failures, analyze the reasons behind them, and propose solutions. Ultimately, this translates to a best-practice 3D registration network (BPNet), constituting the first learning-based method able to handle previously-unseen objects in real-world data. Our model generalizes to real data without any fine-tuning, reaching an accuracy of up to 67% on point clouds of unseen objects obtained with a commercial sensor.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-11-19T19:24:27Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.