From statistical dependence to the space of possible superdeterministic theories

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2509.23047v1
• Date: Sat, 27 Sep 2025 01:52:48 GMT
• Title: From statistical dependence to the space of possible superdeterministic theories
• Authors: Mordecai Waegell, Kelvin J. McQueen,
• Abstract summary: We argue that physical theories that systematically violate statistical independence should all be understood as superdeterministic.<n>We argue that superdeterminism is incompatible with free will according to some prominent compatibilist accounts.
• Score: 0.0
• License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
• Abstract: Bell's theorem demonstrates that any physical theory that is consistent with the predictions of quantum mechanics, and which satisfies some apparently innocuous assumptions, must violate the principle of local causality. It may therefore be possible to maintain local causality by rejecting one of these other assumptions instead. One possibility that has recently received significant attention involves rejecting the principle of statistical independence (SI). In this paper, we consider the frequency interpretation of SI, which states that $\rho(\lambda) \approx \rho(\lambda | Z)$, where $\rho(\lambda)$ is the relative frequency of an element of an ensemble being in the state $\lambda$, and $Z$ is a label that separates the ensemble into apparently randomly selected sub-ensembles. SI is violated when the sub-ensemble frequency $\rho(\lambda | Z)$ fails to be representative of the ensemble frequency $\rho(\lambda)$. We argue that physical theories that systematically violate SI should all be understood as superdeterministic. This perspective on SI sheds light on a number of issues that are being debated in the superdeterminism literature, especially concerning its scope and philosophical consequences. Regarding scope, we argue that superdeterministic theories fall into three categories, deterministic theories with fine-tuned initial conditions, fluke theories, and nomic exclusion theories. We also argue that retrocausal and invariant set theories need not violate SI, which is contrary to how they are normally presented. Regarding philosophical implications, we argue that superdeterminism is incompatible with free will according to some prominent compatibilist accounts. We also argue that although superdeterminism is conspiratorial, it is not unscientific, but pre-scientific.

Related papers

• Impossible Counterfactuals, Discrete Hilbert Space and Bell's Theorem [0.0]
  Localized model of quantum physics is developed (Rational Mechanics - RaQM)<n>In RaQM, Hilbert states are undefined in bases where squared amplitudes and/or complex phases are irrational numbers.<n>It is concluded that violation of Bell inequalities can be understood with none of the strange processes historically associated with it.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2026-01-21T12:36:29Z)
• Generalised quantum Sanov theorem revisited [13.283296551055734]
  Given two families of quantum states $A$ and $B$, quantum hypothesis testing is the task of determining whether an unknown quantum state belongs to $A$ or $B$.<n>In quantum Shannon theory, a fundamental role is played by the Stein exponent, i.e. the rate of decay of the type II error probability for a given threshold on the type I error probability.<n>In this work, we establish a general formula for the Stein exponent where both hypotheses are allowed to be composite.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-10-07T18:05:25Z)
• Practical Criteria for Entanglement and Nonlocality in Systems with Additive Observables [44.99833362998488]
  For general bipartite mixed states, a sufficient and necessary mathematical condition for certifying entanglement and/or (Bell) non-locality remains unknown.<n>We derive very simple, handy criteria for detecting entanglement or non-locality in many cases.<n>We illustrate these results by analyzing the potential detection of entanglement and nonlocality in Higgs to ZZ decays at the LHC.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-03-21T16:48:04Z)
• Minimal operational theories: classical theories with quantum features [41.94295877935867]
  We introduce a class of probabilistic theories, where system dynamics are constrained to the minimal set of operations.<n>Specifically, the allowed instruments are limited to those derived from compositions of preparations, measurements, swap transformations, and conditional tests.<n>We demonstrate that minimal theories with conditioning and a spanning set of non-separable states satisfy two quantum no-go theorems.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-08-02T16:24:09Z)
• Generalized Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Steering Paradox [18.5699135339787]
  We present a generalized EPR steering paradox, which predicts a contradictory equality $2_Q=left( 1+deltaright)_C$. We test the paradox through a two-setting steering protocol, and find that the state is steerable if some specific measurement requirements are satisfied. Our construction also enlightens the building of EPR steering inequality, which may contribute to some schemes for typical quantum teleportation and quantum key distributions.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-05-06T01:25:11Z)
• Tsirelson's Inequality for the Precession Protocol is Maximally Violated by Quantum Theory [0.0]
  Tsirelson's inequality states that $P_3 leq 2/3$ in classical theory is violated in quantum theory by certain states.<n>We consider the precession protocol in a theory-independent manner for systems with finitely many outcomes.<n>We prove by construction that quantum theory always saturates this bound.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-01-29T13:23:55Z)
• Superdeterminism Without Conspiracy [0.0]
  A non-conspiratorial locally causal model is developed where each pair of entangled particles has unique $lambda$. The model is based on a specific but arbitrarily fine discretisation of complex Hilbert space. It is shown how quantum mechanics might be gloriously explained and derived' as the singular continuum limit of the discretisation of Hilbert space.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-08-22T08:09:22Z)
• A Measure-Theoretic Axiomatisation of Causality [55.6970314129444]
  We argue in favour of taking Kolmogorov's measure-theoretic axiomatisation of probability as the starting point towards an axiomatisation of causality. Our proposed framework is rigorously grounded in measure theory, but it also sheds light on long-standing limitations of existing frameworks.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-05-19T13:15:48Z)
• Aspects of Superdeterminism Made Intuitive [0.0]
  We show that superdeterministic correlations may exist as a matter of principle, but be undetectable for all practical purposes. We also show that probability theory, as a physical theory, indicates that superdeterminism has a greater explanatory power than its competitors.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-05-21T14:59:06Z)
• Discretised Hilbert Space and Superdeterminism [0.0]
  In computational physics it is standard to approximate continuum systems with discretised representations. We consider a specific discretisation of the continuum complex Hilbert space of quantum mechanics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-04-07T18:00:07Z)
• Experimental Demonstration that No Tripartite-Nonlocal Causal Theory Explains Nature's Correlations [3.7055392730866776]
  Quantum theory predicts the existence of genuinely tripartite-entangled states, which cannot be obtained from local operations. In this work, we verify that such tripartite correlations are experimentally achievable.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-01-30T09:00:16Z)
• The Smoothed Likelihood of Doctrinal Paradox [34.534516291695155]
  We show that under mild conditions, the smoothed likelihood of the doctrinal paradox is either $0$, $exp(-Theta(n))$, $Theta(n-1/2)$ or $Theta(1)$. Our main theorem states that under mild conditions, the smoothed likelihood of the doctrinal paradox is either $0$, $exp(-Theta(n))$, $Theta(n-1/2)$ or $Theta(1)$.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-05-11T15:55:47Z)
• $\PT$ Symmetry and Renormalisation in Quantum Field Theory [62.997667081978825]
  Quantum systems governed by non-Hermitian Hamiltonians with $PT$ symmetry are special in having real energy eigenvalues bounded below and unitary time evolution. We show how $PT$ symmetry may allow interpretations that evade ghosts and instabilities present in an interpretation of the theory within a Hermitian framework.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-03-27T09:46:36Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.