Impossible Counterfactuals, Discrete Hilbert Space and Bell's Theorem

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2601.14941v1
• Date: Wed, 21 Jan 2026 12:36:29 GMT
• Title: Impossible Counterfactuals, Discrete Hilbert Space and Bell's Theorem
• Authors: Tim Palmer,
• Abstract summary: Localized model of quantum physics is developed (Rational Mechanics - RaQM)<n>In RaQM, Hilbert states are undefined in bases where squared amplitudes and/or complex phases are irrational numbers.<n>It is concluded that violation of Bell inequalities can be understood with none of the strange processes historically associated with it.
• Score: 0.0
• License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
• Abstract: Negating the Measurement Independence assumption (MI) is often referred to as the `third way' to account for the experimental violation of Bell's inequality. However, this route is generally viewed as ludicrously contrived, implying some implausible conspiracy where experimenters are denied the freedom to choose measurement settings as they like. Here, a locally realistic model of quantum physics is developed (Rational Mechanics - RaQM - based on a gravitational discretisation of Hilbert Space) which violates MI without denying free will. Crucially, RaQM distinguishes experimenters' ability to freely choose measurement settings to some nominal accuracy, from an inability to choose exact settings, which were never under their control anyway. In RaQM, Hilbert states are necessarily undefined in bases where squared amplitudes and/or complex phases are irrational numbers. Such `irrational' bases correspond to conceivable but necessarily impossible counterfactual measurements, and are shown to play a ubiquitous role in the analysis of both single- and entangled-particle quantum physics. It is concluded that violation of Bell inequalities can be understood with none of the strange processes historically associated with it. Instead, using concepts from (non-classical) $p$-adic number theory, we relate RaQM to Bohm and Hiley's concept of a holistic Machian-like Undivided Universe. If this interpretation of Bell's Theorem is correct, building more and more energetic particle accelerators to probe smaller and smaller scales, in the search for a theory which synthesises quantum and gravitational physics and hence a Theory of Everything, may be a fruitless exercise.

Related papers

• Experiment to test the incompleteness of quantum mechanics [45.88028371034407]
  We propose an experiment to test the incompleteness of the standard quantum formalism.<n>We show with simulations that the transmission densities in the standard interpretation and in the double solution interpretation give very different results.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-09-05T08:02:14Z)
• 2-Adic quantum mechanics, continuous-time quantum walks, and the space discreteness [0.0]
  We show that a large class of 2-adic Schr"odinger equations is the scaling limit of certain continuous-time quantum Markov chains (CTQMCs)<n>We construct new types of continuous time quantum walks (CTQWs) on graphs using two symmetric matrices.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-02-23T03:10:55Z)
• The composition rule for quantum systems is not the only possible one [0.0]
  We argue that the composition postulate deserves to be experimentally scrutinised independently of the other features of quantum theory.<n>We formulate a family of operational theories that are solely distinguished from standard quantum theory by their system-composition rule.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-11-24T19:31:13Z)
• Minimal operational theories: classical theories with quantum features [41.94295877935867]
  We introduce a class of probabilistic theories, where system dynamics are constrained to the minimal set of operations.<n>Specifically, the allowed instruments are limited to those derived from compositions of preparations, measurements, swap transformations, and conditional tests.<n>We demonstrate that minimal theories with conditioning and a spanning set of non-separable states satisfy two quantum no-go theorems.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-08-02T16:24:09Z)
• Testing trajectory-based determinism via time probability distributions [41.99844472131922]
  We introduce a prescription for constructing an arrival-time probability distribution within generic trajectory-equipped theories.<n>We derive a conditional probability distribution that is unreachable by quantum mechanics.<n>Our results can be tested experimentally, thereby assessing the validity of trajectory-based determinism.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-04-15T11:36:38Z)
• Quantum Liouville's theorem based on Haar measure [0.3124884279860061]
  Liouville theorem (LT) reveals robust incompressibility of distribution function in phase space, given arbitrary potentials. We develop quantum Liouville theorem (rigorous incompressibility) for arbitrary potentials (interacting or not) in Hamiltonians.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-12-08T01:34:32Z)
• (Almost-)Quantum Bell Inequalities and Device-Independent Applications [3.7482527016282963]
  We present families of (almost)quantum Bell inequalities and highlight three foundational and DI applications. We derive quantum Bell inequalities that show a separation of the quantum boundary from certain portions of the no-signaling boundary of dimension up to 4k-8. We provide the most precise characterization of the quantum boundary known so far.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-09-12T15:13:02Z)
• Superdeterminism Without Conspiracy [0.0]
  A non-conspiratorial locally causal model is developed where each pair of entangled particles has unique $lambda$. The model is based on a specific but arbitrarily fine discretisation of complex Hilbert space. It is shown how quantum mechanics might be gloriously explained and derived' as the singular continuum limit of the discretisation of Hilbert space.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-08-22T08:09:22Z)
• Consistent Quantum Causes [2.1756081703276]
  The Consistent Histories approach provides such a theory.<n>It justifies the usual laboratory intuition that properly tested apparatus can reveal the earlier microscopic cause.<n>The use of quantum circuits in discussions of quantum information in a time-irreversible manner can prevent the proper identification of earlier causes.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-03-23T19:09:02Z)
• Discretised Hilbert Space and Superdeterminism [0.0]
  In computational physics it is standard to approximate continuum systems with discretised representations. We consider a specific discretisation of the continuum complex Hilbert space of quantum mechanics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-04-07T18:00:07Z)
• Experimental refutation of real-valued quantum mechanics under strict locality conditions [15.98149438495762]
  Physicists describe nature using mathematics as the natural language, and for quantum mechanics, it prefers to use complex numbers. Recently, it has been shown that a three-party correlation created in entanglement swapping scenarios cannot be reproduced using only real numbers. Our results violate the real number bound of 7.66 by 5.30 standard deviations, hence rejecting the universal validity of the real-valued quantum mechanics to describe nature.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-01-11T20:00:17Z)
• Gentle Measurement as a Principle of Quantum Theory [9.137554315375919]
  We propose the gentle measurement principle (GMP) as one of the principles at the foundation of quantum mechanics. We show, within the framework of general probabilistic theories, that GMP imposes strong restrictions on the law of physics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-03-28T11:59:49Z)
• Observers of quantum systems cannot agree to disagree [55.41644538483948]
  We ask whether agreement between observers can serve as a physical principle that must hold for any theory of the world. We construct examples of (postquantum) no-signaling boxes where observers can agree to disagree.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2021-02-17T19:00:04Z)
• Topological Quantum Gravity of the Ricci Flow [62.997667081978825]
  We present a family of topological quantum gravity theories associated with the geometric theory of the Ricci flow. First, we use BRST quantization to construct a "primitive" topological Lifshitz-type theory for only the spatial metric. We extend the primitive theory by gauging foliation-preserving spacetime symmetries.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-10-29T06:15:30Z)
• Bell's theorem for trajectories [62.997667081978825]
  A trajectory is not an outcome of a quantum measurement, in the sense that there is no observable associated with it. We show how to overcome this problem by considering a special case of our generic inequality that can be experimentally tested point-by-point in time.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-01-03T01:40:44Z)
• Does Bell's theorem apply if perceived pseudo-Euclidean space is emergent? [0.0]
  
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2001-05-06T19:37:23Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.