Comment on "The unphysicality of Hilbert spaces" (arXiv:2308.06669v3)

• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2501.03294v2
• Date: Mon, 03 Feb 2025 14:55:44 GMT
• Title: Comment on "The unphysicality of Hilbert spaces" (arXiv:2308.06669v3)
• Authors: Nivaldo A. Lemos,
• Abstract summary: This is a thoughtful dissection of the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics. It seeks to pinpoint difficulties inherent in postulating that the physical states are elements of a Hilbert space.
• Score: 0.0
• License:
• Abstract: ``The unphysicality of Hilbert spaces'' by Carcassi, Calder\'on and Aidala (arXiv:2308.06669v3) is a thoughtful dissection of the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics that seeks to pinpoint difficulties inherent in postulating that the physical states are elements of a Hilbert space. Its pivotal charge against Hilbert spaces is that by a change of variables, which is a change-of-basis unitary transformation, one ``can map states with finite expectation values to those with infinite ones''. In the present comment it is shown that this statement is incorrect and the source of the error is spotted. In consequence, the purported example of a time evolution that makes ``the expectation value oscillate from finite to infinite in finite time" is also faulty, and the assertion that Hilbert spaces ``turn a potential infinity into an actual infinity'' is unsubstantiated. Two other objections to Hilbert spaces on physical grounds, both technically correct, are the isomorphism of separable Hilbert spaces and the unavoidable existence of infinite-expectation-value states. The former is of little relevance but the latter remains an issue without a fully satisfactory solution, although the evidence so far is that it is physically innocuous. All in all, while the authors' thesis that Hilbert spaces must be given up ought to be taken seriously, it seems insufficiently supported to be convincing.

Related papers

• Generic Hilbert Space Fragmentation in Kogut--Susskind Lattice Gauge Theories [0.0]
  We show that Kogut--Susskind formulations of lattice gauge theories give rise to Hilbert space fragmentation. Our findings serve as a guide to the conditions under which these models can be faithfully used to infer the thermalization properties of quantum chromodynamics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2025-02-05T19:00:04Z)
• Hilbert space separability and the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen state [0.0]
  We propose a test that witnesses the non-separability of the Hilbert space. We consider the original Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) state as a candidate for possessing nonlocal correlations stronger than any state in a separable Hilbert space.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-12-02T19:00:03Z)
• Strict area law entanglement versus chirality [15.809015657546915]
  Chirality is a gapped phase of matter in two spatial dimensions that can be manifested through non-zero thermal or electrical Hall conductance. We prove two no-go theorems that forbid such chirality for a quantum state in a finite dimensional local Hilbert space with strict area law entanglement entropies.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-08-19T18:00:01Z)
• A non-hermitean momentum operator for the particle in a box [49.1574468325115]
  We show how to construct the corresponding hermitean Hamiltonian for the infinite as well as concrete example. The resulting Hilbert space can be decomposed into a physical and unphysical subspace.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-03-20T12:51:58Z)
• Generalized Stein's lemma and asymptotic equipartition property for subalgebra entropies [12.294224442885891]
  We show that the assertion of the generalized quantum Stein's lemma is true for the setting where the second hypothesis is the state space of any subalgebra $mathcalN$. As an application in resource theory, we show that the relative entropy of a subalgebra is the dilution cost under suitable operations.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2024-01-05T23:46:53Z)
• The Fermionic Entanglement Entropy and Area Law for the Relativistic Dirac Vacuum State [44.99833362998488]
  We consider the fermionic entanglement entropy for the free Dirac field in a bounded spatial region of Minkowski spacetime. An area law is proven in the limiting cases where the volume tends to infinity and/or the regularization length tends to zero.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-10-05T12:08:03Z)
• The unphysicality of Hilbert spaces [0.0]
  We argue that Hilbert spaces are not suitable to represent quantum states mathematically. The main point of the paper is to raise awareness that results that rely on the completeness of Hilbert spaces may not be physically significant.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-08-13T03:03:22Z)
• Connecting classical finite exchangeability to quantum theory [45.76759085727843]
  Exchangeability is a fundamental concept in probability theory and statistics. It allows to model situations where the order of observations does not matter. It is well known that both theorems do not hold for finitely exchangeable sequences.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2023-06-06T17:15:19Z)
• Continuous percolation in a Hilbert space for a large system of qubits [58.720142291102135]
  The percolation transition is defined through the appearance of the infinite cluster. We show that the exponentially increasing dimensionality of the Hilbert space makes its covering by finite-size hyperspheres inefficient. Our approach to the percolation transition in compact metric spaces may prove useful for its rigorous treatment in other contexts.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-10-15T13:53:21Z)
• Contextual unification of classical and quantum physics [0.0]
  We develop the idea that the usual formalism of quantum mechanics stops working when countable infinities of particles are encountered. This is because the dimension of the corresponding Hilbert space becomes uncountably infinite, leading to the loss of unitary equivalence. We show that it provides a natural way to describe the "Heisenberg cut", as well as a unified mathematical model including both quantum and classical physics.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2022-09-03T16:51:19Z)
• Discrete Hilbert Space, the Born Rule, and Quantum Gravity [0.21320960069210473]
  Quantum gravitational effects suggest a minimal length, or spacetime interval, of order the Planck length. This in turn suggests that Hilbert space itself may be discrete rather than continuous. We discuss this in the context of quantum gravity, showing that discrete models indeed suggest a discrete Hilbert space with minimum norm.
  arXiv  Detail & Related papers  (2020-07-25T14:13:04Z)

This list is automatically generated from the titles and abstracts of the papers in this site.

This site does not guarantee the quality of this site (including all information) and is not responsible for any consequences.